Y Cyfarfod Llawn

Plenary

17/11/2026

This is a draft version of the Record that includes the floor language and the simultaneous interpretation. 

[R] indicates that the Member has declared an interest when tabling the business.

The Senedd met in the Chamber and by video-conference at 13:30 with the Llywydd (Huw Irranca-Davies) in the Chair.

1. Questions to the First Minister

Prynhawn da. Good afternoon, everybody. 

Welcome back. We will move immediately to questions to the First Minister. Question 1 [OQ64914] from James Evans is withdrawn. Question 2, Andrew R.T. Davies. 

The COVID-19 Review

2. Will the First Minister make a statement on the delivery of the COVID-19 review that has been commissioned by the Welsh Government? OQ64931

If I may, at the start of this session, Llywydd, take this opportunity to congratulate the men's Wales rugby team—[Applause.]—on their magnificent victory against the All Blacks on Saturday. You made history, all of you.

History was made, with immense courage and determination. Many congratulations to you.

To the question today, the review will ensure that Wales has learnt the lessons of COVID-19 and is better prepared for future pandemics. Delivered by an independent expert panel, it will assess whether changes made since the pandemic are delivering real improvements in Wales, and identify if gaps remain where, perhaps, we need to do more. We owe it to those who lost their lives, and everyone affected, to ensure that lessons translate into lasting change.

Thank you for that answer, First Minister. Could you inform the Chamber as to when you had your road to Damascus moment and the conversion from having a public inquiry to this review that you've commissioned, because, obviously, you're on record, as recently as November 2025, saying that we need a public inquiry? Your health Minister was negotiating with the COVID bereaved families up until March 2026. So, when exactly did you have that moment of conversion from the benefits of a full COVID inquiry, with compulsion on witnesses to give evidence under oath, to this much weaker format that you've put forward as a Government, in the review format?

This is about doing the right thing, and I firmly believe that this is the right decision. I have followed the pandemic, as so many of us have, very, very closely over nearly seven years now, as shadow health Minister and then in other roles since. To me, the key thing, and what became clear to me, is that what is missing currently is the shining of the light on the evidence that we have, on the lessons that have been put in front of us from a Welsh perspective. It was never going to be the case that a UK inquiry would ask first and foremost, 'What does this mean for Wales? What's here for Wales? What's the Welsh story here?' That is precisely what this independent review will allow to happen now, looking at those fundamental questions about what happened here, what the lessons are for care homes, hospitals, families and Governments here in Wales. I am determined that we will use this opportunity to make sure, as I say, that we are better prepared for when that pandemic, sadly, will strike again, though, hopefully, not for a very, very long time.

Llywydd, three families, including the families of front-line health and social care workers who lost their lives during the pandemic, were repeatedly told by senior Plaid Cymru figures, including the now First Minister, that Wales would have its own independent public inquiry. Many took those assurances at face value—they really did. Now, after entering Government, Plaid Cymru insists that a review was always the policy. Does the First Minister accept that there is clearly a real gap between what many families believed they had been promised and what is now set to be delivered? And if Ministers told grieving families that Wales would get an independent public inquiry only to then reverse that course after entering into Government, why should those families not see this as a breach of trust?

Llywydd, I think we can be really clear on this. It's a strange situation we're in, in many ways, that we are being criticised as a Government for delivering exactly what we said we would in our manifesto. So, it's not a question of whether I have, for example, changed my mind from thinking that a statutory judge-led inquiry was the right thing to do; I certainly did. We were the first party to call for that. What has happened over the course of time, and learning lessons, and seeing what has emerged from the UK COVID inquiry, crucially—we can't pretend that that hasn't happened—is that I, and we, have come to a position of thinking, 'We can learn these lessons quicker, more effectively, by shining a light from a Welsh perspective'. We're doing what we said we would, and we're doing it for a very good reason, because we believe that we really need to learn the lessons of COVID for when that next pandemic comes.

Good afternoon, First Minister. 

I want to offer you a way out here, because I think it really is quite appalling. Many of us sat in the other Senedd, listening, and I know there are not many here who heard you and other Ministers say that this is what you were calling for. Surely, the people you need to listen to are those with lived experiences. You have said time after time that all of your information, all of your inquiries, everything you aim for is about listening to people. And what is not Welsh about the COVID bereaved families Cymru? They have the experiences, they are really not emotionally resilient anyway, and they've really been battered by this decision. So, I really just want to say to you: I don't understand why you're not going ahead with it. The COVID bereaved families have offered you an inquiry at £10 million. They've given you a model. They've met for three months, they've met with the health Minister—formerly spokesperson—and they've come up with a model. So, please, the door is still open. A good Government can change its mind, and I want you to be a good Government. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

13:35

I'm not going to go back on what we said we would do in our recent manifesto—it's just six months ago. We said we would bring in a review to learn the lessons of COVID, and that's precisely what we are doing. Over nearly seven years, as I say, I, the Member, all of us, have no doubt listened to many people and their thoughts on what might we be able to do differently in future. There are those who tell me now, 'You're doing the right thing. It's the review that we want. You don't want to be spending a certain amount of money on an inquiry'. I don't think it's about the money so much; there will be a cost attached to a review too. If we're serious about doing this, we're going to do it properly. But it is the case that there are significant costs linked to statutory inquiries. Now, it may be the case that, on other issues, a statutory inquiry, with the expenditure that is needed, is the right thing to do. I just happen to think—and I've come to a conclusion over some time—that we're doing the right thing here. Ultimately, if we believe that all we are doing as a Government is about seeking the right outcomes, if the outcome we're looking for is to make sure that we're better prepared for the next pandemic, we're on the path to securing that through this independent review.

One of the most important ways we can honour everyone who has been impacted by COVID is by ensuring that their experiences lead to ongoing change. I welcome the commitment of the Government to ensure that lived experience steers the review. First Minister, could you give people across Wales certainty that their voices will help to design the findings of the review, as well as the practical steps that we will take to make a more resilient Wales that is ready for the future?

An important point was made there, Llywydd, namely the need to ensure that people's voices are heard. The panel, with an independent chair, will operate independently of Government and will decide for themselves how best to work with those people and those groups who have been impacted and who want to share their own experiences. People's lived experience will be a hugely important part of the review. Our expectation is that this panel will reach out as far as possible to ensure that people can contribute their views.

Regeneration and Safety of Coal Tips

3. What steps is the Welsh Government taking to support the regeneration and safety of coal tips in communities affected by Wales’s industrial past? OQ64956

This Government is committed to ensuring sustained investment and action to support communities living with the legacy of that industrial past of ours. I saw that work first-hand when I visited Cwmtillery earlier this month, to see the completed first phase of improvement works and to meet residents affected by the landslip there from the coal tip, some two years ago now, almost exactly. This year, over £80 million is being committed to coal tip safety, supporting work to secure more than 400 sites across Wales.

Diolch, Brif Weinidog. It's really lovely to hear about your visit to Cwmtillery. Next week, of course, marks two years since the landslip that happened there, reminding us of the lasting impact our industrial legacy continues to have on communities across Wales. Ralph and Tina, who you met during your visit, and we got to visit on Friday, are a real inspiration. Despite losing their home during the landslip and still being unable to return there to this day, they continue to give so much through Pentref Tyleri, which is a community-led project regenerating former mining land and showing what local people can achieve when given the opportunity to shape their own communities. Their work highlights why coal tip safety must go hand in hand with that wider regeneration. So, Prif Weinidog, how will the Welsh Government work with the UK Government to secure that longer term funding needed to make our coal tips safe and also regenerate those communities that have been affected?

13:40

I very much enjoyed meeting Tina and Ralph during my visit to Cwmtillery. It was good to be able to hear first-hand about their experience, still not able to return to their home two years on. It was remarkable to see their commitment, I must say, to the community's future. Initiatives like Pentref Tyleri show what can be achieved when communities take the lead in making their areas better places to live.

We will continue to press the UK Government for the necessary funding to protect our communities and help secure and restore sites for current and future generations. This legacy predates devolution. Clearly, the precedent is clear, but we will work jointly. Joint Welsh Government and UK Government investments mean more than £230 million has been committed to coal tip safety in recent years, but this must be the beginning. We need further commitments from the UK Government, and my Ministers have, in the months since we have come to Government, taken that argument directly to UK Ministers to make sure that this legacy is addressed.

First Minister, last month, I tabled a written question to the Cabinet Minister for Rural Resilience and Sustainability about progress on establishing a mining legacy working group, which was a commitment of the last Welsh Labour Government. Obviously, such a group would be crucial to understanding and remedying the challenges posed by the legacy of our coal industry and meeting those points around regeneration and safety especially. In the Cabinet Minister's response, he said that such a group is currently being considered. So, my question is when can we expect the results of that consideration. This is a topic that is so important to my constituents who really want their voice to be heard.

I'm grateful to the Member for continuing to press the case. It is my understanding too that the development of a mining legacy working group is currently being considered as part of a wider approach to addressing mining legacy sites across Wales. We certainly, as a Welsh Government, recognise the importance of collaborating across a range of policy areas, working with different organisations across a number of different sectors, and reflecting the very complex nature of what we're dealing with here in terms of the safety, environmental, social and economic challenges associated with Wales's mining legacy. We certainly are interested in making sure that we have those groups that we can work with in finding ways to address those issues.

There are almost 2,600 monitored disused coal tips in Wales, with 368 assessed as having the potential to impact public safety by being classified as C or D, and 93 per cent of category C and D tips are located in the south Wales Valleys. First Minister, your party's manifesto promised, and I quote, to,

'Deliver a national programme to secure and restore disused coal tips, ensuring every tip is properly monitored, maintained, and remediated.'

Now, despite individual funding for some and some monitoring announcements, your Government has yet to publish one complete national delivery plan, a single comprehensive, fully funded and publicly available tip-by-tip plan, setting out which disused coal tips require immediate remediation. When will you publish this, and can you guarantee to us all here today that this will not become yet another broken Plaid Cymru manifesto promise? Diolch.

Over 4,000 inspections have been completed across Wales since work began on this in 2020, and 750 or so have taken place since April this year. This is an ongoing process. But that's the point—we are, after a slow start, essentially, now recognising in Welsh Government, both current and previous, the importance of making sure that we have measures in place to deal with our industrial past. The next step in this story is the establishment of the disused tips authority in Wales, to be established in April next year, based in the heart of coalfield communities in south Wales, bringing together specialist expertise, innovation and statutory responsibility together in one dedicated organisation. This is one problem that will not be resolved overnight; that's the whole point. But it is why we need that concerted effort, which we're determined to drive forward in the Welsh Government. 

13:45

Diolch, Niamh, for raising this issue. Last weekend, I visited the Sirhowy valley country park in Niamh's constituency and heard about plans for the disused coal tips on the mountain above Bedwas and Cwmfelinfach. I understand that a private company has made a deal with Caerphilly County Borough Council to extract coal from two of the four tips, something that's causing a great deal of anxiety to local residents. But even if the company can address all local concerns around pollution and the potentially devastating impact on the Sirhowy valley country park and the community farm there, the fact remains that there can be no justification for extracting coal to be burned as fuel in 2026. Will the First Minister call a moratorium on all further coal extraction in Wales? And what representations is he making to the UK Government to include a ban on coal tip extraction in the Energy Independence Bill?

I can confirm that it is very much the policy of this Government to make sure that we do not allow the extraction of coal from tips. There may be some reason why, for safety purposes, it may be necessary to do so, but as a matter of principle in terms of extracting coal for burning, it is something that we need a very determined and controlled phasing out of. The Member has my assurance on that.

Questions Without Notice from the Party Leaders

Questions now from the party leaders. I first call on the leader of Reform UK, Helen Jenner. She is not present. The leader of Welsh Labour, Ken Skates.

Diolch, Lywydd. On behalf of Welsh Labour, can I also put on record my congratulations to the men's Welsh rugby team on that historic victory? May it long be repeated on the field as well as in our memories.

Diolch yn fawr iawn. First Minister, almost half of Wales's health board chief executives have left or have announced their departure over the last six months. This is obviously deeply worrying right now as we enter an incredibly stressful period, the winter period. In addition, all of those leaders who have gone or are going are women. Do you believe that there is a reason for this?

Firstly, I must say, Llywydd, whilst I'm delighted to be able to answer questions from the leader of the Labour group, it is quite remarkable that we don't have here today the leader or in fact any members of the Reform group. We are elected here to do a job of work for the people of Wales to form a Government or to hold Government to account. To not take every opportunity to do so is a dereliction of duty.

I think the pressures within the NHS are clear for all to see. We certainly saw it when we came into Government in terms of understanding from a different perspective the real pressures—funding, partly, but also the way the NHS has been supported in recent years. That strain on a health service can manifest itself in many different ways. What I will say is that, through the budget today, through our actions since coming into Government with additional investment, not just as a flow of money but as an improvement in the flow of patients through the system, we have shown, I believe, that we are determined to create that new sense of sustainability that I hope will be felt by the patients and staff, including in leadership positions across the NHS.

Diolch, First Minister, but it is worrying that almost half of those chief executives have announced they're going or have gone, especially that all of them are women. We must wonder whether there's a connection between leadership instability and deteriorating performance. Of course, with leaders going, waiting lists rising and response times for the most serious calls deteriorating, it does feel like we're at risk of a health emergency as we enter the winter.

Plaid Cymru promised those affected by dementia a 12-week diagnosis target and more capacity for diagnosing dementia, as well as faster access to assessment and treatment. This is a welcome set of pledges. Yet six months into Government, families are now being told that they'll need to wait until the publication of a dementia strategy at some point in the next year to find out if any of these commitments will actually go ahead. As I said, there are a number of pledges that are really valuable, but the main one—the most important one—is perhaps that 12-week target for diagnosis. Are you able to tell us today specifically if that 12-week diagnostic target will be delivered as promised? 

13:50

On the initial point that the Member pursued on leadership, leadership is something that we have recognised, as a Welsh Government, is very important. It's why we have made the announcement in recent weeks to establish a school of leadership for the public sector in Wales. It's in order that we can make sure that we have the skills across the public sector, and the structures within the public sector, to make leaders feel equipped to drive the kinds of changes that this new Welsh Government wants to see.

On dementia, again, lack of action in recent years means that we do face a significant challenge. We do think it's the right thing, and we have support in doing so from those involved in dementia care, to develop a new dementia strategy. Part of that dementia strategy is to make sure that we are clear with people about the expectations, what they should be able to expect from the Welsh Government. We will make sure that we get that right, working with third sector groups, working, more importantly, with families and people living with dementia, so that we can make sure that dementia care in Wales improves greatly on the position that it's been in in recent years.

Diolch, Lywydd. Can I congratulate Reform UK on doing all they can to fulfil their manifesto commitment to reduce the size of the Senedd? They seem to be doing rather well in that respect. [Laughter.] And, of course, I also want to put on record my congratulations to the Wales team on that fantastic and historic win over the weekend. Let's see, First Minister, if you can perform as well as they did this afternoon, because I also want to question you on the subject of our national health service, because it's in a precarious state. I think we'd all agree that things are not as they should be.

Last week, the media featured the case of Pam Smith, an 81-year-old cancer patient who spent two days in the Royal Gwent Hospital trying to sleep across three plastic chairs in a room that her family and nursing staff described as a cupboard. The north Wales coroner also last week published two reports following the cases of 67-year-old Janet Nixon and 88-year-old Dorothy Evans, who waited for 17 hours and 24 hours respectively for ambulances, and then went on to die.

And in the news today is another horrible case of a 68-year-old, Andrew Railton, who sat in a chair in a draughty corridor for more than 50 hours on not one occasion, but two occasions, when he attended the A&E department at the Royal Glamorgan Hospital. Six months ago, you promised the people of Wales that you would cut NHS waiting lists, tackle corridor care and relieve pressures in our emergency departments, yet cancer patients are sleeping on chairs in cupboards and coroners are issuing warning after warning about people dying. Can you tell us what's actually improved in the NHS since you took office?

It's precisely because we have come all too aware of stories like that that we have taken the actions that we have taken since coming into Government. Only today, my health Minister is publishing a new plan for acute and emergency care, because we understand that there is so much that needs to be done to improve the experience that patients have when they enter the care system in that way. Twenty-three million pounds has been made available today. It's about making sure that we tackle corridor care—which is unacceptable and bad for health treatment—and that we move patients through the system quicker.

That's only one part of the way that we are addressing the challenges. There's the investment of around £150 million in surgical hubs to make sure that we're bringing people into the system quicker. That is the change that will lead to the eradication of those two-year waits. But we can't wait for that, either. We need to see action actually making a difference to the experience that patients have all the way through the system. I believe that the actions that we are taking are providing exactly that.

13:55

First Minister, you referred to the framework that's been published today on emergency and acute care. I read that framework. It does promise improvements, but not until 2034. That's the date that you're aiming to deliver the improvements by, which of course is well beyond your term of office. People need to see improved care now, not in 2034, not even in three years' time, which the framework goes up to. They need to know that, if they phone for a GP appointment, they can get one; that if they phone for an ambulance, one turns up in time; that if they turn up in an emergency department, they're not going to be stuck there for many, many hours; and if they need to be admitted to a hospital bed, that they can have access to a bed and will be seen properly.

In your manifesto prior to the Senedd election, you promised, and I quote, to

‘Tackle corridor care by increasing the number of beds on Welsh hospital wards’,

yet there's no reference to increasing the number of hospital beds in the emergency and acute care framework published today. So, can you tell us, does that commitment to increase the number of beds still stand, or have you abandoned it like you abandoned the commitment to the COVID-19 bereaved families? And if it does still stand, how many extra beds are you going to provide, in which hospitals will you provide them, and by when will they be delivered?

Just as we are delivering exactly as we said we would on the COVID review, we are delivering exactly as we said we would on improving patient flow through the system. Will we provide extra beds where they are needed? Absolutely, we will look for ways to make sure that we bolster the system to make sure that we have the right beds in the right place.

I was at a district general hospital just a few weeks ago. It was not extra beds that they were looking for to improve the flow of emergency patients through the system. It was all the way through the system, from contact with primary care in the first place, right through to the support given through social care, and getting patients out of hospital. Because patients want to be in hospital getting the care that they want, and they want to leave that hospital as quickly as possible in order to be able to get better elsewhere. That is what the staff were telling me that they needed, and that is what this £23 million is set to do today—tackling corridor care way before the timescale that the Member suggested. Because we cannot wait to ensure that we provide the people of Wales with trust in the system, the health system that they are so dependent on.

Before we progress, just to save any other Member also having to say it, on behalf of all the Senedd Members here present today, can I congratulate the Wales team and wish them well for next week as well? A cracking result. 

Question 4 [OQ64928] from Claire Johnson-Wood is withdrawn. 

Misnformation ahead of Elections

5. What action is the Welsh Government taking to protect the public from misinformation ahead of elections in Wales? OQ64922

The Welsh Government is committed to strengthening integrity in politics and works closely with partners to protect the integrity of elections. The Electoral Commission, the electoral management board, the UK Government and Ofcom all have key roles in tackling mis-, mal- and disinformation. Ahead of next year's local elections we are supporting the electoral management board to improve the award-winning Vote.wales, which gives voters reliable information on voting and on candidates.

Firstly, I think it's disgraceful that Reform haven't turned up today on one of the most important days of the year, which is the budget. In those five hours they've probably cost over £7,000 in salaries collectively. But in recent weeks we've seen parties in this Chamber—Reform—claiming credit for decisions that were never theirs to make. People are entitled to disagree with this Government and to hold it to account hard, but they're not entitled to misrepresent the facts, and voters expect better in May. So what more can be done to make sure people in Wales can trust what they're told by those that they elect?

The truth of the matter is that it suits some in politics to undermine trust in politics itself. It is incumbent on all of us who believe in the democratic system, all of us who bothered to turn up to work today, to show that people can trust that we are doing what we are doing for the right reasons. There might be different political opinions, there might be different viewpoints, but ultimately strengthening always the foundations of our democratic system is something that should be important to all of us. It is clear for all to see that there is one party in the Senedd that is more interested in undermining our democratic institutions than strengthening them. 

In the last Senedd, the Senedd Cymru (Member Accountability and Elections) Act 2026, of course, imposed a duty on Welsh Ministers to prohibit making false statements of fact during a Senedd election in order to affect the return of a candidate—a good example there of trying to build that integrity in the system. Now, the Government is considering the best way to discharge that duty. It's an innovative piece of legislation, noting the debate in the last Senedd, acknowledging that this is a complex area to legislate in. I would, of course, remind all Members that the Members' code of conduct was updated by the last Senedd. It clearly states that Members must not make deliberately misleading statements. I guess you have to be here to make any statements at all.

14:00

First Minister, you talk of integrity in politics. Can you not hear how that completely contradicts the assurances that your party gave COVID bereaved families in the lead-up to the Senedd elections? Indeed, on 19 March, ahead of the elections in May, one of your Ministers, after initially telling those COVID bereaved families they'd no longer support an inquiry, went on to say that they had communicated badly the type of inquiry that they were setting up and there was no rolling back on that commitment. On the same day, another Member of your Cabinet said to those COVID bereaved families that they were proposing a focused inquiry with clear, concise terms of reference.

You talk about integrity in politics, and the question, the substantive question, referencing the lead-up to an election—. Yet here we have a rolling back of a clear commitment that your party made in the lead-up to these elections in May. So, First Minister, given that these things were said just ahead of the elections in May, what is your view on these statements, and do you believe they constitute mis- or disinformation?

I'm trying to think how much time I have to remind ourselves of all things that Conservative politicians have said and then reneged on over the years. But the question at the heart of this, and it's an important one in terms of integrity, and it's something that I've certainly discussed both as a journalist and as a Member, is—. We've put manifestos before an electorate, and it's quite important, I think, that we stick to what we say we would do, and that's exactly, of course, what we've done on the COVID review.

Question 6 [OQ64939] not asked.

Question 7 [OQ64957] not asked.

Data Centre Capacity

8. What assessment has the Welsh Government made of Wales’s data centre capacity needs? OQ64960

Wales will need access to data centre and computer capacity as artificial intelligence, cloud services and the wider digital economy develops. The question, though, is not simply how many data centres we will need, or what size and so on in the future, it’s about ensuring the right type and the right location, the right capacity, while taking account of energy issues, water issues, land issues, environmental impacts, resilience and economic benefits. There's a whole load of things we need to get right here. That assessment is informing our strategic policy framework for data centres and AI computer infrastructure currently under development.

Diolch, Brif Weinidog. I'm really glad to hear you say that, because in the Economy, Energy and Connectivity Committee recently we heard that the Global Centre of Rail Excellence will require a data centre onsite, and from the information they provided to the committee, it appears as though this data centre may be one of the largest in the world, bigger than the current proposed largest one in Scotland. This data centre in Scotland is estimated to use the same amount of energy as 2 million homes, and the data centre proposed on the GCRE site in Wales could be even bigger than this one in Scotland. So, potentially, it could use the same amount of energy as double the number of homes in Wales. There's just so much we don't know about it. Currently, there are an estimated 21 data centres either in operation, in proposal or in development in Wales, but, again, we don't know for certain what that number is because they're all going through local planning systems. So, I wonder what assessment Welsh Government has made of the potential cumulative impact of all these different data centre proposals on their energy use but also in achieving net zero by 2040?

I know the Member would recognise that it wouldn't be appropriate for me to comment on specific projects or proposals because that could prejudice the role of Welsh Ministers in the future, should planning applications come before Ministers for determination. Of course, in more general terms, it really is important that we recognise that data centre growth can place significant demands on the electricity system, for example, and raises a number of different questions. We're considering future demand and needs alongside grid capacity, energy generation, our statutory climate commitments too, which are very important, with individual proposals subject to appropriate planning consenting and environmental assessment processes.

It's really important that we get this right. There's a risk that there's a default 'Data centres are bad' that could develop, and I think that would put us at a disadvantage. I'm thinking about the AI capacity that we will need to develop health diagnostics and cancer treatment in future, so we'll need data centres. But we need to get it right in a way that works for Wales, that makes the most of skills that we have, the capacity that we have, but recognises the importance of mitigating and saying 'no' where necessary on energy or water grounds. That is why it's really important to get this framework right, which is what the Government is determined to do. 

14:05

Question 9 [OQ64916] not asked.

The Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse

10. What consideration has the Welsh Government given to recognising the European Day for the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse? OQ64962

We recognise the importance of the European Day for the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse. This year’s focus on ethical media reporting reinforces the importance of protecting children’s rights and privacy. Our focus is on sustained action, of course, to prevent child sexual abuse, to strengthen protection measures and to support victims and survivors, and all that will be underpinned by our 10-year national strategy.

Diolch yn fawr. The European Day for the Protection of Children against Sexual Exploitation and Sexual Abuse, marked on 18 November each year, was established by the Council of Europe in 2015, building on the Lanzarote convention, which commits countries to preventing and tackling the sexual abuse and exploitation of children. Senedd Cymru is committed to the well-being and protection of children, and I very much welcome that this Senedd's cross-party group on the prevention of the sexual abuse of children met yesterday for the first time. This important group reflects at a Welsh level the core objectives of the European awareness day by providing a forum to raise awareness, promote dialogue, amplify survivor voices and drive continued action to prevent child sexual abuse. Considering the Senedd's commitment to this work, will the First Minister consider formally adopting and recognising this important European day in Wales to clearly show our collective commitment to protecting children?

Thank you for the question.

I certainly recognise the important role that the European day can play in raising awareness of child sexual abuse and exploitation, and I welcome the renewed focus that the cross-party group brings to this issue. I will consider how we can best recognise and support the aims of the day in Wales, but our commitment, of course, must go beyond any single day. Our 10-year national strategy is about sustained action to prevent abuse before it happens, to protect children when concerns arise and ensure that victims, survivors and their families do receive the support that they need. That is how we will continue to demonstrate our commitment to protecting children in all parts of Wales.

Corridor Care

11. What action is the Welsh Government taking to address corridor care in north Wales? OQ64917

Corridor care is unacceptable. It compromises patient safety and dignity and increases pressure on staff. Later today, the Cabinet Minister for Health and Care will publish a new policy framework setting clear expectations for health boards to end routine corridor care. In north Wales, our escalation intervention is focused on strengthening clinical leadership, governance and safety. We have also invested targeted funding to clear discharge bottlenecks that keep people waiting in corridors.

Diolch. Almost 89,000 patients were treated in hospital corridors, cupboards and, generally, in rooms not suitable, and this was between 2022 and 2025. One thousand and twenty-seven people died whilst awaiting A&E treatment in that health board area between 2023 and 2025. Patients at Ysbyty Glan Clwyd often spent around 10 hours in corridor care, on average, last year, the longest of any north Wales hospital. Ysbyty Glan Clwyd is an absolute disgrace—not the staff or the consultants, but, generally, the actual running of that hospital. The longest period that a patient, however, stayed in a corridor was over five days at Ysbyty Gwynedd. No-one should have to spend their hours or even days in a hospital corridor. Every single patient, individual, deserves dignity.

First Minister, NHS England have formally defined corridor care, but they regularly publish data. Now, in Wales, Royal College of Nursing Wales and British Medical Association Cymru have repeatedly called on you and your health Minister for the same transparency, a formal definition and mandatory monthly reporting by every health board. Will this new policy framework that your health Minister is bringing forward this afternoon include that transparency? Will you act on those calls today? We've got to stop corridor care now.

14:10

That is absolutely one of the elements that we seek to address. One of the things that we need to do is define exactly what 'corridor care' means. We all have a sense, but in terms of measures that we take within the health service, it's very, very important that we have that definition, and the work is being done right now under this plan to develop that definition.

I'll return to a word I used a minute ago—'dignity'. This cuts to the fundamentals of treating patients with dignity in the health system. There is nothing worse for a nurse or another health worker to know that they are treating a patient in a way that doesn't offer them the dignity that they were trained to offer and that is their calling. We're determined to make a change on this. It's not going to happen overnight, but this £23 million injection of funding now, together with the steps that will flow from it, will, I'm confident, make a difference.

I was pleased to stand on a manifesto that committed to end corridor care, and welcomed the announcement made by the Plaid Cymru Government this week that that would be done by 2029. I am aware of the correspondence that I received from constituents that this continues to be a challenge in north Wales. It's good, therefore, to see a Government taking action urgently to resolve the issue.

Does the First Minister agree with me that delivering this target would not only mean that every patient receives appropriate treatment, in a dignified manner, but that it would also improve the environment and working conditions for the incredible staff within the health service who have faced challenging working conditions too often in the past?

I agree with that entirely, because, clearly, we put most of the focus on the patients and the treatments that the patients receive, but so often I do feel for the staff, as I said a second ago, who know that they have to provide care in circumstances that are either difficult in terms of providing that care, or circumstances that they know fall far below the standard that they would like to provide.

I am confident that the announcement today will give hope to patients and staff that we are on the right path. Yes, funding is associated with this, but there is also a change of attitude, including defining what exactly 'corridor care' means and so forth. There is an expectation that we eliminate this practice and this is the Government taking steps towards that.

The Mineworkers' Pension Scheme

12. What representations has the Welsh Government made to the UK Government about releasing the guarantor’s fund for members of the mineworkers’ pension scheme? OQ64933

In his recent UK Government budget, the Chancellor of the Exchequer committed to deliver the full transfer of the remaining guarantor’s fund to members. While I welcome that intention, there is still no firm timescale for releasing the undistributed surplus, and we will continue to raise that with UK Government.

14:15

First Minister, in November 2016 this Chamber agreed a Plaid Cymru motion tabled in your name and moved by Steffan Lewis. It called for a review of the 50:50 split of the miners' pension scheme surplus. Will you write to the Chancellor and the Prime Minister, on behalf of the former miners in Wales, pressing them to release the fund in full, and publish a timetable so members know when their pensions will go up?

As I said, I welcome the Chancellor's commitment to transfer the money in full, and to resolve the issue in weeks, not months. We need to hold them to that and, given the specific request, I am happy to write in the way the Member asks. Given the importance of this issue to former mining communities across Wales, I will reinforce the need for that commitment to be delivered swiftly, and for former miners to be given a firm timetable for the transfer.

And thank you also for reminding us of how long we have been making the case for this, and for reminding us of the work done by the brilliant Steffan Lewis in standing up for his community.

2. Business Statement and Announcement

We will now move to item 2, the business statement and announcement. I call on the Trefnydd, Heledd Fychan.

Thank you, Llywydd. There are no changes to Government business this week. Clearly, Members will be aware that there was a debate put forward by Reform UK on freedom of speech. The status of that debate is not clear at the moment to me as Trefnydd, therefore I hope that we will have clarity on that shortly. Draft business for the next three weeks is shown on the business statement, which is available to Members electronically.

Diolch, Lywydd. Trefnydd, I'd like to request a statement from the Deputy Minister for Skills and Tertiary Education on the Welsh Government's approach to apprenticeships in Wales. And, Llywydd, I declare an interest and refer Members to my register of Members' interests, as my wife works for a further education provider in west Wales.

Now, before the summer, the Welsh Government announced a national skills audit, which is something I was calling for in the previous Senedd. I'm keen to hear more about how that work is progressing, particularly alongside the Welsh Government's national strategy for skills and vocational education. This Government has the chance to really establish some parity of esteem between vocational and academic education, but we won't achieve that if the sector is not properly supported. Therefore, I'd be grateful if we could have a statement on apprenticeships and vocational education and training so that we can learn more about the work that is being done to establish parity of esteem, and also to hear more about how the Welsh Government is supporting FE providers across Wales.

Well, I thank the Member for raising that issue. As you will know, Cefin Campbell is leading on the work in terms of the skills strategy. But it's relevant to all portfolios, of course. It's relevant to the portfolio that I lead on, as well as all other Ministers'. So, I will make Cefin Campbell aware that you raised this point. Of course, we will update the Senedd as this work proceeds. It's extremely important, in terms of delivering this Government's programme for government, that we develop skills in many areas where there are currently gaps. So, I thank the Member for raising this issue.

Diolch, Drefnydd. I would like an urgent statement, please, from the Government about the potential merger of the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency with the Driver and Vehicle Standards Agency. The DVLA is a big employer in Swansea. Indeed, I used to work there myself as a summer job when I was in medical school. The news last week that Andy Burnham, in his quest to rewire the state, is considering merging the DVLA with the DVSA, or indeed potentially abolishing it entirely, as was the fate of NHS England, was not welcomed in Swansea. This would be a major short-circuit in this rewiring, in fact. Almost 6,000 people are employed at its headquarters in Morriston, looking after 53 million drivers and, after recent reverses with Admiral, Swansea University, the health board, and the nearby Tata steelworks, any threat to the DVLA would be catastrophic to our city. Diolch yn fawr.

Well, as the Member has outlined, the DVLA is an important employer for Swansea and the region more broadly, and we would expect any proposals that affect its future to recognise that economic importance, and we would try and engage early with the UK Government regarding any consequences for the workforce in Wales. The Member, of course, will be aware that there are no formal proposals put forward as yet, and therefore it's too early to make comments on the virtues of any proposed model. Although this is an issue for the UK Government, in terms of the decisions on the structure of the DVLA and the DVSA in the future, we would expect the Welsh Government to be included fully in any proposals that could impact on the provision of driver and vehicle services in Wales and, as I said, the economic impact.

14:20

Trefnydd, I'd like to request a statement from the Cabinet Minister for Health and Care on the decision of Cardiff and Vale University Health Board to roll back on chaplaincy provision in their hospitals. People across Wales, those with a faith and those without, would recognise the important spiritual and emotional support that chaplaincy services provide, especially to those who may be facing the end of their lives, or those who have recently experienced a bereavement. And, as chair of the cross-party group on faith, I was disappointed to see that the health board has decided to remove weekday, evening and overnight out-of-hours chaplaincy provision from 30 November this year. The importance of spiritual care is recognised in Welsh NHS guidance, which identifies 24/7 provision as the appropriate level for hospital settings. Its firm opinion is that this level of service should always be provided. So, I would request a statement on the provision of chaplaincy services as soon as possible.

I thank the Member for raising this issue; it's an issue that will be very important to many constituents for the reasons you've outlined. I understand from the Minister that you have written to him on this issue. He is aware of it and I understand that he will contact the health boards asking for an update.

Prynhawn da, Drefnydd. I'd like to request a statement, if I may, from the First Minister, who I understand is responsible for international affairs, on the tragic humanitarian situation in Gaza. Floods in early November destroyed more than 6,000 family shelters and, according to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, families who had already lost their homes and their loved ones woke to find their tents underwater. Five people, three of them children, died when an embankment collapsed onto their tents where they were sheltering. Hundreds of thousands of people are living in places at high risk of flooding, and this is only the first storm of this winter. Tents and essential supplies are sitting at the border, ready to go into Gaza, and the UK Government has joined others in saying that this situation is entirely reversible. Across Wales, people are heartbroken by what they are seeing and many, we know, have given generously. They will want to know that Wales is using its voice too. So, I'd be pleased to know exactly what the Welsh Government is doing in order to add its voice to the UK Government's call for aid to be let in without delay.

Well, I thank the Member for raising this issue, which I'm sure is of great importance to all Members here. The further humanitarian suffering in Gaza following the recent floods and heavy rain is a very severe situation. The continuous restrictions on international aid don't help anyone, and the international community and everyone who has a voice in this need to increase momentum in trying to end the suffering of people in Gaza and accelerate the two-state solution.

The Member will be aware that providing international aid is outside the devolved remit of the Welsh Government, and the response of the Welsh Government to an international crisis is by supporting, usually, the disasters emergency committee in Wales. If they launch an appeal, a contribution will be considered by the Welsh Government at that point in the context of funding priorities and the budget that is available. But, certainly, in terms of using our voice internationally here as a Senedd, as we have done as a Senedd, it's important that we continue to speak up against suffering in Gaza. 

May I ask for a statement from the Cabinet Minister for Culture and Sport as Welsh Athletics' excellent Own the Night campaign comes to an end for another year? I recently had the privilege of meeting Gwen from Môn Girls Run to hear about the negative experiences that they've had as a group when running at night since the clocks went back. That included cars beeping, people wolf-whistling and some men, who were strangers, even running alongside them. Women shouldn't have to change their routines or limit their physical activity because the nights are drawing in, and I'm proud of the work that groups like Môn Girls Run and Welsh Athletics do in highlighting these experiences and raising awareness of the challenges. I would ask the Minister to make a statement noting the value of the work that's been done over recent weeks, and restating the Government's commitment to ensuring that women and girls can exercise safely all year round. 

14:25

I thank the Member for raising this issue. As an opposition Member, I sponsored the Own the Night celebration a year ago. As Minister, I have declared my support, and the Government as a whole has committed to ensuring that everyone has the freedom and the confidence to use public spaces to take part in sports and to exercise without fear of abuse, violence or mistreatment. This is a very important campaign. It shows that we are all responsible as a society for addressing this. Let me be very clear: this is not the responsibility of women and girls; we all are responsible in Wales, and this includes a number of men and boys who have also been supporting this important campaign. There is further work, of course, to do, but there is a cross-Government commitment to ensure that no woman or girl should have to change where they go, what time they exercise, or how they live their lives because they are fearing for their own safety or because that safety is being endangered.

Trefnydd, I would like to request a statement from the Cabinet Minister for Enterprise, Connectivity and Energy on the use of traffic regulation orders. Now, TROs play an important role in the day-to-day lives of communities across Wales. However, recent examples have highlighted how the current system can often create unnecessary confusion. The issue stems from the standard wording used in many orders, which frequently refers to a period of up to 18 months. While this reflects the maximum duration, many residents understandably interpret this as the length of time closures or works will actually be in place, and there have been several examples of this in my own constituency. Most recently, National Highways had to reassure residents that the M48 project had not been delayed for a further 18 months, despite what some believed a newly published order suggested. I would therefore welcome a statement from the Cabinet Secretary on whether the Welsh Government will review the way traffic regulation orders are communicated to the public, with a view to providing clearer information. Greater transparency would help avoid confusion and ensure communities are better informed about the impact of these works on their daily lives.

I thank the Member. The Deputy Minister for Transport would lead on this on behalf of the Welsh Government. Clearly, he has heard your comments. I would suggest that you write to him with those specific examples. I know that in a minute it's difficult to elaborate on them, but he could then look at them in more detail.

I'd like to request a statement, please, from the Government, on the legacy planning associated with the Tour de France coming to Wales next summer. While hosting the world's most prestigious cycling event presents a significant opportunity to increase participation in cycling and promote active lifestyles, at the same time, there is growing concern about the future of Cardiff's Maindy velodrome. Maindy is one of Wales's most important grass-roots cycling facilities, which has played a central role in developing cyclists at all levels for generations, including Geraint Thomas, but it is in immediate need of urgent investment. Cardiff Council's current legacy proposals are focused on a closed-road cycling circuit, but questions remain around funding, and, since it is scheduled for opening in 2028, it will not be available to use by anyone inspired to take up cycling immediately after the Tour. Can the Welsh Government therefore provide a statement on how it intends to ensure the Tour de France leaves a meaningful and lasting legacy for cycling in Wales, and how the future of facilities such as Maindy velodrome will be safeguarded as part of this vision? Diolch.

Thank you. You're quite right that the Grand Dèpart of the Tour de France in 2027 is an incredible opportunity for Wales, putting Wales on the world stage when the Wales leg starts in Welshpool on 4 July, and ends, of course, in our capital city. It is incredibly important, and I'm sure that the comments I've made about major events thus far have given Members certainty that this is a very important issue for this Government, ensuring the greatest benefit. And this is the sort of thing that we should be looking at before that bid goes in, rather than looking at it reactively.

I would like to pay tribute to the work of the Member in terms of campaigning, in particular when it comes to the velodrome in Maindy, which is something that I campaigned on when I represented that region of South Wales Central at that time. And I know that Members have been campaigning for many years on this issue. 

You have also written to me recently on this issue as well, and it is therefore clear that it is Cardiff Council that needs to lead on any bid for funding; we do not directly fund. There is funding that has been invested by this Government in terms of ensuring a legacy for the Tour de France, but, certainly, we would hope that Cardiff Council would look at what you've raised with them. 

14:30

Business Minister, can I please request a statement from the Cabinet Minister for health about the Rare Cancers Act 2026? September marks six months since the Act became law, and whilst primary responsibility lies with the UK Government, it is incumbent on all nations, including Wales, to maximise the opportunities of patients with rare and less survivable cancers, like stomach, oesophageal, and pancreatic cancer. 

This new Act is intended to overhaul access to innovative treatment, clinical trial recruitment, and research co-ordination for patients with rare and less survivable cancers across the UK, including Wales. Yet, I understand from the response to questions I asked during the summer recess that the Cabinet Minister for health is not aware of any discussions between health bodies in Wales and those in England responsible for the implementation of the Act, half a year after the Royal Assent. Given this apparent lack of engagement, will the Cabinet Minister for Health and Care make a statement on the steps he intends to take to direct health and research bodies to initiate formal discussions with his UK counterparts, and also outline what measures the Government will introduce within the Wales cancer strategy to ensure that patients in Wales are not left behind in accessing the sorts of clinical trials, innovative treatments and research co-ordination promised by this legislation? Thank you.

I thank the Member for raising this issue. Clearly, the Cabinet Minister for Health and Care has heard your comments, and the commitment that I can give is that this is part of the cancer plan, that we look at all cancers in Wales, and want to give due attention to all of them. 

Trefnydd, I'd like to ask for a statement by the Deputy Minister for Social Care, Mental Health and Women's Health regarding waiting times for neurodevelopmental assessments. We know that reducing waiting times for such assessments is a priority for the Welsh Government, and I welcome the fact that health boards are going to receive a proportion of the £5.6 million through the neurodiversity improvement programme, with the aim of eradicating waiting times of over three years for neurodevelopmental assessments for children. 

However, I hear increasingly about the impact that this has on provision for adults, with a number reporting long waiting times for autism assessments. There is also concern regarding young people awaiting assessments through the children's services system, who could reach the age of 18 before they reach the top of the list. So, a statement outlining how the Welsh Government intends to support health boards to manage the transition process, particularly when adult services already face such long waiting times, would be of interest to Members in the Chamber today—perhaps not today, but in this Chamber in general—and those who work on the ground. Thank you. 

I thank the Member for raising very important issues, and for advocating so strongly on an issue that I know many of us will have received a great deal of correspondence on from constituents, and we will have advocated ourselves on behalf of constituents because of those problems. And that is the work that is ongoing by this Government, in looking at how we can ensure that improvement, whilst recognising that the situation as it currently stands is not as it should be. 

There are major challenges because of those waiting times, as you've outlined in terms of those assessments, and we will continue to work with partners in order to identify where improvements can be made, because there must be improvement, and that's the commitment of this Government. 

Thank you, Presiding Officer. Leader of the house, could I seek a statement from the Minister for the economy in relation to the Brocastle enterprise park? 'Enterprise' is now most probably the furthest away from the state of that enterprise park—it's a rubbish dump. In August, a load of travellers occupied the site, and despite my best efforts with the department to try and seek notices to evict these travellers because of the mayhem they were causing to local residents—letting livestock out of fields onto the public highway, terrorising a nursing home that specialises in dementia treatment and dementia patients—now the site is covered in refuge, asbestos sheeting, fibreglass sheeting, disused caravans and black-bin-bag waste thrown everywhere across the site. The lighting on the site has been totally vandalised, in that air guns or something have been used to shoot out the glass on all of the lighting that's on the site. This is a real dereliction of duty on the department to safeguard taxpayers' money and taxpayers' assets. But the first priority has to be to make sure that this site is now cleaned up and is put to good use as an enterprise park to create jobs. So, can we have a statement from the department, highlighting how they're going to restore the site back to its original concept, so that people can look at it and think seriously about building units that can create employment opportunities for the local community?

14:35

The Deputy Presiding Officer (Kerry Ferguson) took the Chair.

I thank the Member for raising this matter. I'll certainly make the Cabinet Minister for Enterprise, Connectivity and Energy aware of what you have outlined. I don't know whether you have written to him as well, but certainly, if you haven't, I would urge you to do so. But, as I said, I will be making him aware. You have painted a very vivid picture of the challenges that this creates for constituents, so thank you for raising this issue.

3. Debate on a Statement: The Draft Budget 2027-28

We will now move to item 3, debate on a statement: the draft budget 2027-28. I call on the Cabinet Minister for Finance, Elin Jones.

Diolch, Ddirprwy Lywydd. I propose the budget motion in the name of Plaid Cymru. Romantics amongst you might think of this as a budget 100 years in the making. For realists, it's a budget a little more than 100 days in the making. Most definitely, it is this century's only budget since Wales beat the All Blacks. But for this hardened pragmatist, 27 years in this Senedd, it is a personal honour today—

It is a privilege.

—and a political privilege to propose Plaid Cymru's first ever budget for Wales.

I've witnessed Labour finance Ministers propose 26 budgets to the Senedd, from Edwina Hart's first to Mark Drakeford's final budget last year. There have been years of plenty for finance Ministers—big, real percentage increases to the block grant—but there have been years of austerity too. My timing to Government has me at the wrong end of the austerity-to-plenty spectrum. My timing in Government has also served me quite well, it seems. Am I the only finance Minister or Chancellor ever in the UK, or in the world, to turn up on budget day and have the opposition decide to take the day off? [Interruption.] The official opposition—the important ones are here.

This budget's numbers were confirmed by the UK Chancellor's autumn budget three weeks ago. There is a 0.5 per cent real terms cut to our resource budget in 2027 and 2028, and a 10 per cent real terms cut in our capital budget between now and 2029-30. This is against a backdrop of global uncertainty, which is continuing to affect growth and inflation across the United Kingdom. Excluding the COVID years, this is the worst year-on-year position since George Osborne, the architect of austerity, was Chancellor, in 2014-15. It has necessitated very difficult decisions for my fellow Ministers.

There are, of course, choices in setting budgets. The UK Chancellor could have made choices to increase public expenditure in order to protect public services against real terms cuts to spending, thereby increasing Wales's block grant. He chose not to do so. There were choices open to the Welsh Government too, to increase the pot of public money available to spend by increasing taxes. We have chosen not to do that. Given increasing interest and mortgage rates, any upward movement in our land transaction tax would not have been helpful to the housing market. Given this Government's commitment to helping households with the cost-of-living burdens faced by so many people, an extra penny on the main rate of income tax would certainly have been counterproductive to that effort, especially given that we currently have no control over income tax thresholds, which could be used to shield lower earners from such an increase.

However, it is important to emphasise that these are real choices. An additional £389 million of funding available to public services in Wales from an extra penny on rates of income tax would have made allocations in this budget look very different today.

You will have heard me speak of the three pillars of this budget: a first pillar to fund effective public services supporting people, businesses and communities all over Wales; a second pillar to fund the priorities brought into Government by Plaid Cymru and now actioned in our programme for government; and a third pillar to work with other political parties to fund your priorities and ensure that a final budget can command a majority across this Chamber. The budget is therefore a blend of all three, and all three pillars are of equal political importance to me in building a successful budget.

To our public services, then. This draft budget provides over £500 million of additional resource funding for NHS services in 2027-28, rising by a further £200 million in 2028-29. In total, there is a 4.2 per cent uplift for health and care. There is also £2 billion of capital funding for health services over the next three years. This investment will help our NHS respond to growing demand for care, driven by an ageing population, rising inflation and increasingly complex health needs.

However, additional investment alone is not enough. We are committed to the long-term sustainability of the NHS. We expect health bodies to improve productivity, maximise value for money, and accelerate service modernisation. In post-COVID years, we know that numbers of non-clinical staff have grown at a faster pace than clinical and front-line staff in health organisations. This is not financially sustainable, and I have asked the health Minister to re-balance the NHS in favour of clinical and front-line staff, and work faster to improve productivity within the NHS. We need to transition to a sustainable, affordable and modernised health and care service that focuses on prevention, population need and care closer to home.

The draft budget also provides the local government settlement with an additional £176 million, which results in an average increase in the settlement of 2.8 per cent, recognising the vital role councils play in supporting communities across Wales. Local authorities deliver many of the services people rely upon every day, from education and social care, to housing, leisure services and local infrastructure. In a year where Welsh Government’s budget faces a 0.5 per cent real-terms cut, we have chosen to ensure that local government gets a real-terms increase. We know of the pressures facing every local authority, and we will set a funding floor so that every council will receive at least 2.5 per cent from the outset.

Above inflation increases to the NHS and local government in this, a budget with a real-terms cut of 0.5 per cent—I may say that a few times—means that, across the rest of the public sector, there are reductions or cash-flat allocations. It was available to us, as has been done before, to share the pain of these reductions equally across all sectors and organisations; this has not been our approach. Instead, we have used this tough financial settlement to drive some of the changes we need to see in how, and on what, money is spent by Welsh Government. We are using this first year to begin a deeper transformation of public service delivery and spend.

There are policy programme areas that have struggled to deliver positive outcomes, despite significant Welsh Government spending. On the day when the Milburn review is published, we know that policy instruments in place to reduce the number of young people neither in education nor training have not resulted in the desired effect. Over the next year, and working with changes to come from the Westminster Government, this area of expenditure will be reviewed and re-prioritised. On international spend, the Government will review its effectiveness both in terms of economic promotion and global citizenship. Some programmes will cease and new priorities emerge. On child poverty, which has remained stubbornly high, we will re-design and seek to introduce a pilot direct support payment.

Many public organisations will need to use the opportunity of this budget to work more effectively as stand-alone organisations, or, in the case of some, for example, our commissioners, seek ways to share back-room functions and costs. We will work with the public sector to support finding ways to make better use of resources for front-line delivery and reducing back-room costs and duplication. Using AI properly and effectively will be key to this. We know all of this will require investment. That is why we are establishing a £25 million a year transformation fund to support public services to modernise, improve productivity and deliver better value for the taxpayer.

Turning to the second pillar of the budget, I am pleased that despite the profoundly difficult financial settlement we face, the budget allocates funding to roll out our programme for government and to make possible the priorities we promised to the people of Wales in the election. Our commitment to reduce waiting times will be delivered through our significant uplift to NHS spend. We will provide an extra £75 million in 2027-28, and an additional £111 million in 2028-29, to support our ambitious commitment to universal childcare for children aged nine months to four years by the end of this Senedd term. This significant investment will help parents into work, education and training, ease pressures on household budgets and ensure more children get the best possible start in life.

We are also prioritising economic growth through our enterprise budget. We are investing over £20 million in 2027-28, rising to over £30 million in 2028-29, to establish our new business-led national development agency. The agency will help Welsh businesses start, grow, innovate and export, creating more high-quality jobs and supporting prosperity across our communities. I know that supporting businesses directly through reducing business rates is something that interests members across this Senedd, and I will hope to be allocating additional funding before the final budget to reduce business rates.

I sit here next to the Minister for rural affairs and sustainability. He was probably the first out of the blocks with spending commitments back in the Royal Welsh. This Government is committed to a ring-fenced minimum allocation of over £1 billion to direct farming support over the next three years. Today, this budget puts the first two years of this commitment firmly in our spending plans, giving Welsh farmers the highest level of payment stability they will have had since the time of the common agriculture policy.

This budget also confirms £45 million over three years for coal tip safety, over and above ring-fenced funding from the UK Government, which will see the establishment of the disused tips authority. We are also allocating £2 million in this budget to support mapping and prioritising the restoration of post-industrial land, so that the UK Government can provide the funding needed to fix the harms of Wales’s industrial legacy.

Through this budget, we are also able to make progress on many of the other programme for government commitments, which cut across portfolios through the common themes of prevention, tackling poverty, addressing climate challenges, promoting the Welsh language and boosting productivity. There will be £1.5 billion over three years that will go towards our 20,000 homes target and to support the decarbonisation through retrofit; £4.6 million to fund our Cynnal child payment pilot next year; an extra £10 million to continue our expansion of free school meals in secondary schools, with no reduction in this budget for the school milk subsidy scheme; an extra £3 million to extend our school swimming scheme over the next two years; and £10 million in 2027-28  to deliver the Tour de France and UEFA Euro 2028, when the eyes of the world will be on Wales. And when those thousands of visitors arrive, we want them to enjoy more than just the sport itself. Our museums, theatres, and cultural centres enrich any visit to Wales, and following a decade and more of cuts and funding pressures, we will break the trend that these institutions have endured in previous years of austerity. The budget provides an additional £2 million for culture and sport in 2027-28, rising to £4 million in 2028-29.

I am particularly pleased that we have worked closely with the Wales Green Party on two elements of this budget, as part of our work on this budget’s third pillar of partnership. We are today announcing a climate resilience fund, which will support a step change in nature-based interventions to mitigate extreme weather risks such as flooding, drought and wildfires. We will also invest in community EV car clubs as part of our £30 million investment in electric vehicle infrastructure, which will reduce transport emissions and support the transition to a greener, more sustainable economy. I want to thank colleagues in the Green Party for their early and positive discussion on the budget. Discussions can now move further with other political partners in this Senedd to amend the draft budget or allocate further spending to priorities we share in common in advance of the final budget.

Dirprwy Lywydd, we may have taught the All Blacks a lesson on Saturday, but I will end by suggesting that we can all learn something from the mantra of the All Blacks: leave the jersey in a better place. Change will not happen overnight, but this Government is laying the foundations for a healthier, greener, more prosperous Wales. This budget seeks to protect the public services people rely upon, invest in working families, support economic growth and tackle climate challenges. It reflects the priorities on which this Government was elected and marks the first step in delivering our programme for government. Despite the limitations imposed on us by Westminster, despite the UK Chancellor's choice to impose a real-terms cut on Wales, this is a budget that embraces change, focuses on delivery and invests in our future so that, whenever the time comes for Plaid Cymru to leave Government—in four years' time, in eight years or 73 years—we will have left our nation, our jersey in a better place. I commend this budget to this Senedd.

14:50

Thank you very much, Cabinet Minister. I would usually move to Reform UK, but they are not in attendance, so Huw Thomas to start.

Diolch, Ddirprwy Lywydd. Can I just start by saying how unbelievable it is that the Reform UK opposition are entirely absent? This is probably the most important debate we have had in this Chamber thus far this term. A third of the Chamber, all of Reform UK Members, are absent. That is a disgrace, it has to be said. And, Dirprwy Lywydd, I hope you will allow some extra time for those opposition parties who are here to hold the Government to account as we make our points.

Therefore, may I thank the Cabinet Secretary for her statement this afternoon and for the opportunity to discuss some of the details this morning and the opportunity to see the statement beforehand? We would have had more time if others had been here to ask their questions. The documents are comprehensive and I welcome the commitment that there's been to openness in terms of the changes and how we interpret those changes.

Now, our priority in Welsh Labour is to really focus on whether it will help people with the cost of living and improve people's living standards. We want to see health and wealth for all. We want to see funding that will support the most vulnerable people in our communities, grow our economy and give public services the investment they need.

Before the election, Plaid Cymru knew how much money would be available to them. They even knew that there would be £320 million extra from the UK Government as consequential funding for additional learning needs. Plaid's starting point, as we know, was to allocate zero to help schools on that particular issue. And while we were pleased to secure £60 million in the current financial year, making clear our expectation that more would be required, it is disappointing to note that instead, again, it looks like Plaid Cymru have allocated not a single penny again to ALN for next year's budget, despite the warm words and half-promises to teachers, parents and, importantly, trade unions. So, it's very clear that supporting children with disabilities and special learning needs is not something this Government wants to prioritise, and it will take an intervention from Welsh Labour to do right by our most vulnerable families.

On the health service, the additional investment will, of course, be welcome. But as we've seen in the first six months of this Government, extra money doesn't necessarily translate into better results, with waiting lists, of course, having gone up 30,000 since May. And what about that shift to prevention that was promised? Well, local government has not been prioritised in the same way. Some councils will have an increase of just 2.5 per cent, which will not be enough for them to keep up with rising demands or address the pressures, be that in ALN, social care or on other issues. The Welsh Local Government Association has made a powerful case that the failure to address the pressure on the front line to meet the increase in people needing support and the failure to invest in preventative services will lead to greater need and higher costs in turn for the health service in the future.

Let's be absolutely clear, the funding shortfall that local government faces, as proposed—and I'm quoting WLGA figures here—is well in excess of £0.33 billion. That will need to be addressed through either over 12,000 redundancies, a 17 per cent council tax rise, or some combination of those two—a double-digit council tax increase, Minister, coming just a few weeks after Plaid Cymru delayed making council tax fairer until 2032. So, I ask: how is this Government, how is this budget helping people with the cost-of-living crisis? 

Now, let's not forget the reason that the position is so challenging. The last UK Government spending review actually increased the resources available to the Welsh Government. We've had two years of record settlements and, indeed, an increase to the available money next year as a result of the UK Government autumn budget. I recognise it is a challenging settlement, nevertheless, but the problem is that Plaid Cymru made a series of uncosted pledges in the election without saying where the money would come from, and now Ministers and the First Minister were asked repeatedly what was going to be cut. Well, now, today, we are finding out, as I'm sure Ministers are realising that some of the things that they promised are not going to be deliverable during this term.

Now, we welcome the fact—and I've seen it in the budget—that the budget line on milk in schools has not been cut. So, I'm pleased to see that our campaign is paying off, but, rest assured, we will continue to argue the case in the debate tomorrow. [Laughter.] I mean, the laughter says it all, doesn't it? The laughter says it all. I think you should reflect very carefully on whether laughing about children having access to milk is something you should be laughing about in this Chamber.

But I want to talk about the economy. I want to talk about the economy because what is in this budget to drive the Welsh economy forward, to deliver wealth as well as health, to create, and support young people into, decent employment? The Minister has mentioned the Milburn review published today. That sets a UK ambition to radically reduce the proportion of young people not in education, employment or training. But does the Welsh Government share this ambition? I fear it is moving in the opposite direction, slashing employability programmes and turning potential students away from our further education colleges. As I understand it, the Government is planning to spend £60 million over the next two years on the establishment of a national development agency—this Welsh Development Agency replacement. But this funding seems to be coming from rowing back on job support in the here and now, and failing to properly invest in further education, leaving colleges facing devastating funding pressures. Minister, that logic seems perverse. We welcome steps to attract inward investment to Wales, but those longer term ambitions cannot come at the cost of employment support that's delivering now. Jobs Growth Wales+, for example, has a proven track record of delivery. Since 2022, there have been more than 20,000 starts on that programme, helping thousands of young people move into employment. I've heard already from the sector that they believe this programme could be gone entirely from April. And on further education, which we know is so vital to Wales's economic future, this is cash flat for Medr, with colleges being left high and dry by this budget. There are 5,000 learners in our colleges today with unfunded places. This failure to invest will have devastating consequences, Minister. On the very day that Milburn talks about the employment crisis facing young people, and as the UK Labour Government extends a job guarantee across Great Britain, Plaid Cymru is slashing and burning through the Welsh Government's employability programmes. It won't just hold back our economy, it will condemn the career prospects of a generation of Welsh young people. So, Minister, could you explain why committing that £60 million to the national development agency is so urgent when those cuts have been made elsewhere? What will the money be spent on? How many staff will that agency employ? And how can that be the right priority when colleges and, indeed, higher education are crying out for funding?

Time and time again in this budget—and I stress we've only had the details for some 45 minutes—it looks like Plaid Cymru are prioritising their unfunded manifesto commitments to the detriment of public services we all rely on. To give a very specific example of this, the budget expenditure lines show a reduction of £1.3 million to fire and rescue services. That's a cut of 22 per cent. Can the Minister please explain the justification for that, given the outbreaks of wildfires this summer?

I know, in summing up, that the Minister recognises she will need to work across the aisle to secure a budget deal. There have been constructive discussions, and we want to work with the Government to improve this budget and protect the delivery of Welsh public services. But, Minister, I must say in conclusion that there's an awful lot in here that needs fixing, based on what you are proposing. There will be an awful lot of people in Wales tonight worried for their services and, indeed, worried for their jobs. Thank you.

15:00

I'd like to thank the Cabinet Minister for arranging a meeting this morning to give advance notice of the headlines within the draft budget that she shared with us this afternoon, and, of course, for advance sight of the draft budget this afternoon, as a previous speaker mentioned, just less than an hour ago.

Cabinet Minister, you introduced these documents to the Senedd today as Plaid Cymru's first full budget, which it absolutely is. But when looking around this Chamber, aside from the dereliction of duty by some, we have to acknowledge the reality that this Welsh Government does not hold a majority and does not hold all of the cards with this budget. Of course, Plaid Cymru is the largest party here, but the people of Wales did not deliver them a majority in May. So, as we have heard, there will have to be work with other Members from different parties who represent different politics. Cabinet Minister, I welcomed the end of your statement for all sorts of reasons, but particularly for your acknowledgement of the realities in this Chamber and what the people of Wales voted for in May. Should this budget fail to pass next year, there will, of course, be serious consequences for all of our public services and for people up and down Wales.

With that in mind, I'll say what I said to the last Labour Cabinet Secretary for finance last November during the previous budget process. I said to them then that the Welsh Conservatives are a responsible opposition. We want to see Wales be the best it can be, and we will work with parties to ensure that there is a budget that makes the right decisions with Welsh people's money. The first steps towards that, Cabinet Minister, will be to get Wales growing again. We as Welsh Conservatives are clear that Wales needs growth, investment and jobs. We will not get the growth we need by recycling the same policies that Labour pursued for years or by making the same mistakes that they did: raising taxes, unnecessary expansion of the state, and strangling our economy in more and more red tape.

As Welsh Conservatives, we want a budget that will start by cutting tax. Land transaction tax, business rates, local taxes—all of these are adding to the pressure on households and contributing to Wales's economic struggles. [Interruption.] Are you okay? Okay. Shall I continue, Deputy Llywydd?

If you want to wait a minute. Mike, are you okay? We will adjourn for a moment, if that's okay.

Plenary was suspended at 15:03.

15:20

The Senedd reconvened at 15:20, with the Dirprwy Lywydd in the Chair.

Thank you very much for your patience. Thank you very much. We will move immediately back to Sam Rowlands. Thank you very much.

Thank you, Deputy Presiding Officer. Can I acknowledge the cross-party support from our colleagues here this afternoon and thank all Members, and certainly pass our best wishes on to our colleague who fell ill just a few moments ago?

As I was saying, Cabinet Minister, we want cuts in business rates for our small businesses across Wales. Our manifesto sets out our ambition to scrap business rates for small firms, pubs and post offices. We want to revive our high streets and make the town centre the best place to open a business once again. We want owners to have more money to employ another person, improve their premises and build their business. These are the people creating the jobs and generating the prosperity on which public services depend, and they deserve a Government and a budget that backs them to do that.

Cabinet Minister, one of the most practical steps this Government could take in this budget would be to scrap land transaction tax—also known as stamp duties—on people's primary residences. Land transaction tax is simply a bad tax. It punishes people for moving around on the housing ladder, it makes it more difficult for people to buy their first house, it represents the Government taking a slice of a transaction it should have no business in, and there's growing consensus around this.

Back in 2025, reacting to our pledge to scrap this bad tax, the executive director of the Institute of Economic Affairs said that abolishing stamp duty is the single best reform any Government could make to Britain's tax system. That same year, the Institute for Government recognised that the tax led to inefficiency in the housing system and stopped people moving houses, while acknowledging that restricting labour mobility is bad for the economy.

And Members across the Chamber might also be interested to hear that the first time he ran to be leader of the Labour Party, a certain Andy Burnham called for stamp duty to be abolished. Unfortunately, he has, of course, abandoned this good idea. Even Hannah Fry, the mathematician and broadcaster who many may know appeared on The Traitors this year, has called stamp duty one of the stupidest taxes in the entire world.

Getting rid of this bad tax would mean that Wales's housing market could become more fluid, it would mean people can unlock more of the value of their homes when selling, it would mean people having more money left over when they're buying, and it encourages people to move up and down the housing ladder to find the place that's right for them at the right stage of their life.

And there's a multiplier effect at play here too: scrapping land transaction tax would unlock more of people's money when they move. They can spend this on home improvements, creating more work for plumbers, electricians, carpenters, decorators and carpet fitters, or they can spend it another way. But the key, Cabinet Minister, is that that would be their choice, and that's a key Conservative principle that people know best how to spend the money that they earn. Scrapping land transaction tax on prime residences would be a vote of confidence in the people of Wales. We're relying on them to drive growth through personal choice rather than the technocratic and plan-obsessed pattern we're used to from Welsh Labour.

In our manifesto, we promised caps on council tax so that excessive rises are blocked before they reach people's bank accounts. These, Cabinet Minister, would be truly transformative policies signalling real change and putting more money in the pockets of hard-working workers here in Wales. And of course, as Welsh Conservatives, we recognise that tax cuts must also be funded. That's why it's important to look seriously at how and where efficiencies and cuts can be made in this budget, and I cannot overstate how important it is for this new Welsh Government to focus on using taxpayers' money responsibly. I was actually glad to see a commitment in your manifesto this year when you said you would, and I quote,

'make every pound of the Welsh budget count',

and the Welsh Conservatives absolutely agree with that statement. And we also agree that, and I quote from your manifesto,

'This means ensuring that public money is spent efficiently, and used effectively to improve public services, rather than repeatedly diagnosing problems that then are never fixed.'

So, then I would urge you, Cabinet Minister, to look at how you can work across the Welsh Government to cut wasteful spending and drive up efficiency in the public sector here in Wales. And, of course, I welcome your allocation of £25 million to support these efficiency savings in the public sector. But we want to see you go further, faster, and find where the best savings can be made.

It's crucial that Welsh Government prioritises the areas it does have responsibility for—healthcare and education in particular. You should absolutely stop spending on non-devolved areas like international affairs, which only divert important funds away from devolved areas. And I welcome your commitment on this today in your statement. Savings can be found across Wales and beyond by slashing unnecessary bureaucracy, scrapping wasteful overseas projects and ensuring Government support is targeted at those who need it most here.

They can also be found a lot closer to home. As Welsh Conservatives, in our manifesto, we promised to cap the number of Welsh Ministers to 12 and to cut ministerial pay by 10 per cent, and freeze it over the course of this Senedd. Efficiency in the public sector has to be pursued constantly. Our hard-working doctors, nurses and teachers, to name a few, need to see resources going directly to the front lines of public services here in Wales. What they don't need is more and more managers and bureaucracy.

So, Deputy Presiding Officer, growing Wales's economy and making the most of taxpayers' money will only be the start of reversing 27 years of Labour mismanagement. But it will be a start. And this new Welsh Government has the perfect opportunity now to deliver a new pro-business, pro-growth Wales, where households have more money in their pockets and get the high-quality public services they deserve. That is what we as Welsh Conservatives will be fighting for, and that's what I'm urging this Welsh Government to do in this budget as it develops over the coming weeks. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

15:25

Before I start, I'd also like to extend my well wishes to our colleague and, like Sam, I thought it was great to see colleagues rallying to support a fellow Member.

Dirprwy Lywydd, I welcome the publication of this draft budget, which begins to tell a new story on how the Plaid Cymru Government intends to invest public funds. Every good story has several key elements, but time is short, so today I will focus on just three.

Firstly, the premise. The Government has been clear that the financial context in which this draft budget is set is extremely challenging. I welcome this honesty and it's a message worth repeating, because it highlights once again how the current devolution settlement limits Wales's ability to unleash its full economic potential. But the key thing here is that the finance Minister has not allowed the real-terms cut imposed by Westminster to prevent the Welsh Government from investing in its key priorities. Bringing down waiting lists, raising standards in our schools, tackling child poverty, boosting productivity, and rolling out the most generous childcare offer anywhere in the UK are all aspirations progressed by this draft budget.

Which brings me on to the second element of this story—the plot.

The Plaid Cymru programme for government sets out clear objectives and priorities that are supported by this fiscal envelope. The story is one of identifying challenges, showing dedication and ambition, developing bold yet realistic policies that will move our nation one step closer to overcoming some of the gravest injustices of our time.

Despite decades of investment, child poverty levels are appallingly high, Wales sits at the bottom of the Programme for International Student Assessment educational standards tables once again, and the cost-of-living crisis is a cause of concern and worry to far too many households the length and breadth of Wales. That's why I applaud this Government's approach in taking a different approach with this budget: investing more strategically, with a focus on output rather than on the scale of the expenditure itself; recognising that there are more productive and efficient ways of running the Government itself and allocating funds to realise that ambition; and taking a fresh look at nearly 1,000 expenditure lines, asking the question, 'Is the funding truly going to the right area for the right reasons?' These are the common themes throughout this budget, and that's why it tells such a compelling story of a Government that is determined to avoid repeating past mistakes.

Finally, no good story is complete without a compelling cast list. For Plaid Cymru, who we are and what we're about has always been the people of Wales. They are central to our story. It is their priorities, their ambitions and their aspirations for the future that are reflected and represented in this draft budget. 

Coming from a background in education, I am particularly pleased to see this investment in giving every child the best possible start in life. The expansion of free school meals in secondary schools, alongside funding for the Cynnal child payment and the 'Foundational Literacy and Numeracy Plan', reflect this Government’s belief that there can be no better investment than in our young people’s future.

I also welcome the investment in our skilled and valued education workforce, with a 3.5 per cent pay increase for teachers, school leaders and FE lecturers. I know that many Members across this Chamber feel as passionately as I do about education, and so I look forward to following the progress of discussions between the Government and opposition parties, in the hope that any alliances that can be built will strengthen this budget even further for learners, parents and teachers.

Dirprwy Lywydd, to close, 'Change the story, change the world' is how the saying goes. This new story being told by the Plaid Cymru Government today may not change the world, but it is my hope and belief that it can begin to change Wales for the better. Diolch.

15:30

Can I thank the Finance Minister for her statement today, and say that I'm looking forward to detailed scrutiny of the budget? Obviously, we've just had these figures. There's a lot to take in there, and the committees will have a really important role to play.

If I can just start by raising the issue of the Medr funding, which is indeed deeply worrying, I know that you are aware of how worried we are about the participation pressures that exist today in FE, and what this means for our FE learners going forward. The irony of such a challenging settlement for Medr on the day that Milburn publishes his report on young people who are not in education, employment or training is not lost on me, really, and I really hope that this is something that we can look at.

I am concerned about the ALN money as well, and I wanted to ask about that, because it was my understanding that the Government had done a deal with the Association of School and College Leaders that was a three-year deal, which would have meant more money this year—which, obviously, we built on with our £60 million—£60 million for the year that this budget covers, and then a recurrent £80 million going forward. And I am very concerned, if ASCL withdrew from any action because assurances were given by the Government, that that money is now not in the budget. Because I don't think it would be the right thing to do to assume that other parties are going to fill in the gaps of things that should be there. So, I would like an answer on what's in there for ALN, what discussions have been had with ASCL, and whether those discussions have been honoured.

I wanted to ask about Jobs Growth Wales. You'll have heard me raising concerns about Jobs Growth Wales. This is a crucial programme that funds organisations like ACT in my constituency, and in constituencies across Wales. It is working with learners who are furthest from employment. Some of them are really vulnerable, have mental health issues, so I would like to know what this budget means for them.

I note from my very quick looking at the budget expenditure line tables that there seems to be a reduction in the budget for the whole-school approach for mental health. So, I would like to ask about that, and just say to the finance Minister that that's something of a red line for me, really, that we protect our spending on support for young people in schools. I know that that is jointly with the health budget, so maybe there's an explanation for that, and, if so, I would be keen to hear it.

Obviously, we all welcome more funding in the NHS. But I specifically wanted to ask about mental health there as well, and to ask whether the Plaid Cymru Government remains committed to the mental health ring fence that has been in place now for many years in Wales, so that we can be assured that, of that extra money, mental health funding will be protected. Diolch yn fawr. 

15:35

I welcome the opportunity to comment on the first-ever Plaid Cymru budget. When people talk about the NHS, the issue raised most often is waiting lists. People want to know that they can access treatment when they need it, and I am pleased that this budget recognises that priority. It not only sets in motion the work of tackling waiting lists and pressures today, but it also begins the longer-term task of building a health service that is more resilient and better able to meet the future demands through a strong focus on prevention.

Despite a very challenging context—and I don't think we can underestimate the scale of the challenge here—I am encouraged that the new Welsh Government is taking those steps towards creating the efficient and modern health service that we desperately need. Even in the first few months that Plaid Cymru have been in Government, it is clear that things are different. I have been pleased to see the Government deliver major investment in elective care hub capacity, providing an additional £100 million for reduced waiting times, securing jobs for 253 graduate nurses, and appointing Wales's first Minister for women's health so that greater attention can be given to areas of care that have not always received the focus that they deserve.

Bringing down waiting lists is rightly a priority in this budget. Just as importantly, it begins to lay the foundations for a stronger and more sustainable NHS in the years ahead. Alongside tackling today's pressures, it sets a clear direction of travel for our health service, with a greater emphasis on prevention and public health. That means moving beyond simply treating illness and managing symptoms towards addressing the causes of poor health and helping people stay healthier for longer. As someone who has spent a decade working to improve support for young people with diabetes during their adolescence, but always with one eye on how that support could help set them up for lifelong health, I know first-hand how precious our NHS is and how important it is that we get these decisions right. We need a service that is fit for purpose today, but is also prepared for the challenges that lie ahead and the futures that we can build. The choices we make today will shape our health service for years to come. This budget is only the beginning, but it is a positive step in the right direction.

Thank you very much for the work. Many thanks.

This budget announcement comes after a summer of extreme heat and wildfires, where communities across Wales are seeing the effects of climate change on their doorsteps. Families are now facing another winter of rising fuel costs and flood risks. So, I thank the Cabinet Minister for listening to our calls to take climate resilience seriously and for understanding the critical role that nature-based solutions will play. The new climate resilience fund, of at least £55 million, that we've called for will help to deliver the necessary longer-term investment needed to keep our communities safe. Healthier rivers, more resilient farmland and stronger natural defences will help to mitigate against climate impacts, helping to keep homes, businesses and communities safer for generations to come.

I'd like to thank the national stakeholders we've worked with for their help. They rightly argued that an investment in climate resilience will have wide-ranging additional benefits over and above helping prepare for extreme weather events. This will reduce carbon emissions, restore biodiversity and reassure our rural communities. We will now, of course, continue to scrutinise the Government to ensure that delivery maximises the benefits to people and to planet, and we expect to see robust monitoring of outcomes to assure Welsh communities that public money is no longer subsidising environmentally damaging activities.

The Welsh Government has also allocated £30 million over three years for vehicle electrification, and yet 20 per cent of households in Wales have no access to a car, and families might not be able to justify owning a car or be able to afford one. I was therefore delighted yesterday afternoon to visit TrydaNi, who run community car share clubs across Wales, providing affordable access to electric vehicles and supporting rural connectivity. TrydaNi's electric car borrowing service has been extraordinarily successful since they launched in 2019, but their success depends on the reliability of their service: people need to know that a vehicle will be available when they need one. This investment will help organisations like this grow. Our work with Welsh Government to ring-fence at least 10 per cent of this new funding for community electric vehicle car clubs will help to support more sustainable, inclusive and greener transport options for the people of Wales.

Both the investment in climate resilience and in electric vehicle infrastructure are real wins for the voters and people across Wales, who told us very clearly in May that they expect politicians from all parties to work together constructively to address the climate and nature emergencies. Today's announcement proves that politicians who take their mission seriously can deliver real change for Wales.

I'd also like to touch upon some other key areas in the budget. We're pleased to see that the budget contains indicative spend for three years. This gives greater certainty to public bodies and commissioned services to plan beyond the immediate term of just one year at a time. The increase of £176 million for local government, as well as the commitment to implement a funding floor of at least a 2.5 per cent uplift each year, is welcome and will help councils deliver the public services we all rely on. On housing, the additional £1.5 billion for new sustainable social homes, as well as retrofitting existing homes, is vital to ensure that everyone in our society has a safe, warm place to live. I do, however, regret that the budget for housing support and homelessness prevention has remained frozen, meaning a real-terms cut for services. All Members will be aware of the increasing demand and complexity of need within housing services, so I urge the Government to go further in the final budget.

Finally, I want to reflect on the future of spending on the Government's international strategy. I understand these budgets have been consolidated within the First Minister's own portfolio, but, in the context of the climate crisis, the Government must emphasise global solidarity and partnership and resist calls from other parties—who are not present today, perhaps—to water down our global commitments.

15:40

I welcome the opportunity to respond to the publication of the Welsh Government's draft budget for 2027-28, unlike Reform, who it seems aren't here and have managed to silence themselves. I welcome this budget, because it's come from a Government that has met three key tests. Six months ago, people voted for change. They voted for more investment in the NHS to bring down waiting lists. They voted for a transformational childcare policy to help thousands of households across Wales. They voted to spread prosperity and boost productivity. And they voted for a Government with the courage to break with the past and leave behind Labour's business-as-usual budgets and to ask not just how much money is spent, but how is that money spent. To do this takes fresh thinking and a commitment to making Government work better for the people of Wales, despite the colossal financial challenges we face. I'm pleased to see that new approach running right through this budget and, as a consequence, it meets the test of delivering the change that was overwhelmingly supported on 7 May.

Secondly, as the Minister has said, with the exception of the COVID years, our nation faces the worst real-terms settlement from Westminster since 2014 and the days of George Osborne's austerity. Behind Andy Burnham's rhetoric of solidarity and socialism hides the reality of continued hardship for the Welsh public purse. Now, I welcome the Prime Minister's promise to look at granting greater financial flexibility, but this can't come soon enough. Wales is tired of waiting for Westminster.

Yet, despite our nation, its Parliament and its powers having long outgrown the fiscal straitjacket that hampers our ability to control our own economy, this draft budget reflects a Government that won't let its ambitions be dimmed. It's a budget that meets the challenge of the day and more: more money for the NHS, more money to protect our councils' front-line services, and more money to roll out more hours of funded childcare for more families. All this despite the frustrations and limitations of the current financial settlement and inadequate capital borrowing powers that leave us with a 10 per cent real-terms cut in our capital budget over the coming years.

This meets the final test—a Government unapologetic in championing its priorities. It's not a cobbled-together collection of unstrategic budget lines, it doesn't blindly nor blithely presume that adding layer upon layer of spending leads to better outcomes, despite the historic lack of evidence to back that approach. It is a spending review in all but name, which tells us a new story about Wales. Radical change is not brought about overnight, and any politician who claims otherwise has failed to realise that offering simple solutions to complex problems rarely succeeds. But, for the mother whose mental health is suffering due to spiralling costs of childcare, for the patient waiting in pain for a hip replacement, for the young person worried about their prospect of finding an affordable home, this budget offers hope that a better future is possible, and this Government is determined to build it. 

I began by setting out my belief that this draft budget meets three key tests: delivering change, meeting the challenge and championing this Government's priorities. Despite the weak hand that Wales has been dealt by Westminster and an autumn budget that ignored our nation's needs, I am proud that this new Plaid Cymru Government will not be deterred. 

15:45

First of all, representing my party—I'm not the leader since yesterday, of course—I do want to say that it is so disgraceful that Reform UK are not here to scrutinise a budget for the people that they represent. It is appalling, and I don't know what else to say, but I'm sure it will be clear to them, hopefully, that their position in relation to the Senedd is untenable, and I hope that that will change.

Secondly, can I say that I'm grateful to the Minister for taking the time to discuss this budget with me? 

We all knew that this would be a very difficult budget with very little room for manoeuvre, and I don't envy you, Minister, and your colleagues, the choices that you have to make. I firstly welcome the measures to tackle child poverty. As somebody who, along with others in the Siambr, has fought for a long time to get programmes and measures in place in order to really show a difference to the children who are poor in Wales, I do welcome the investment in childcare that we've seen, including the capital as well, to help expand the settings, and also the Cynnal payment. I very much hope that we're able to get the powers that we need in order to deliver that. Together, they do absolutely represent real progress on tackling child poverty.

And I'm grateful for that.

I do welcome, as well, the Government's aim of moving more care into our communities, but, of course, we know that shift has a cost. You have to build a new service before you can close the old one. And of course, I've mentioned this before, but in Powys we have a real live test right now, with the health board consulting on cutting physical beds from 146 across eight sites to 60 across two sites. And they are promising more care at home. We all want more care at home, of course, but we need to see that, actually, that is going to be funded. We know that care at home in Powys is struggling right now. The health board's own figures show six of its eight community hospitals actually ran at 90 per cent occupancy last year. The delayed discharge rate in Powys this September was two and a half times the average of Wales. So, my concern is that, if we cannot provide care at home now with community beds in place, then how will we manage when they are gone? We know that that care is delivered by our councils, the very bodies being asked to carry the weight of this shift. I do welcome the extra money going to local government and the guaranteed funding floor—something, again, that many of us across the Siambr have fought for. We need to see prevention in place, and I do believe the Government's commitment to that, and early help for families. And both of those things we're seeing in this budget.

I want to finally just focus on a very small line in this budget, which Paul has mentioned—one that, actually, I think, says a great deal about us as a country and this Welsh Government. I was immensely disappointed by this Government's decision to end funding for the Size of Wales and the Mbale tree growing programme. I suspect that if Reform UK had been here right now, we would have heard lots of boos, but this is really important to us. It shows what we are about. It's about climate justice. It's about helping those who don't have what we have. For well over a decade, this partnership has connected Wales with Uganda. It has planted more than 25 million trees and has built real links between our communities. At a cost of around £350,000 a year—little more than a thousandth of 1 per cent of the budget—this is hardly a choice between trees in Mbale and beds in our hospitals. As we know, Size of Wales have told us that the grant will stop in the middle of the planting season, leaving nurseries with seedlings in the ground, and nobody paid to look after them.

So, just to finish, I put three questions to the Cabinet Minister. Firstly, will the Minister confirm that social care will not be left behind in your timetable, and what support Powys and other councils will receive? Secondly, will the Welsh Government agree a funded exit plan for the Size of Wales Mbale programme so that 15 years of work is not abandoned overnight? And finally, still with international issues, Scotland has put £16 million into international development this year; will this Government commit to doing that? Diolch yn fawr iawn.

15:50

One of the main reasons why I got into politics was because of the high levels of child poverty that we see across Wales, and especially in my constituency of Blaenau Gwent Caerffili Rhymni. Almost half of children in Blaenau Gwent live in income deprivation—the highest proportion in all of Wales—and in Caerphilly, nearly one in three children live in poverty. This is completely unacceptable in twenty-first century Wales.

As we all know, poverty impacts a child for the rest of their life, from the day they are born to the day that they die. But it doesn't have to be this way. A child's future should not be determined by the postcode they are born into or the financial circumstances of their family. We have a responsibility to take the bold action needed to ensure that every child in Wales has the same opportunities in life. That's why I'm so proud to see this Plaid Cymru Government investing in those areas that we know can make the biggest difference.

Let's start with childcare. We know that having access to affordable, high-quality childcare can make a real difference for families. Organisations like the Bevan Foundation have repeatedly highlighted how a good childcare system can help families out of poverty, support parents back into work, especially women, and give children the best possible start in life. This childcare offer also helps us in creating a fairer and more equal Wales, especially when we look at the gender pay gap. In Caerphilly, that gap is higher than both the Welsh and UK averages, and making childcare more affordable can help tackle some of those inequalities by making it easier for women to return to work, continue building their careers, and have the same opportunities to progress as everyone else.

Ultimately, by delivering the most ambitious childcare offer anywhere in the UK, we're helping families keep more money in their pockets, giving more parents the opportunities to work, and ensuring that every child has the best start in life.

And then we have the cost-of-living package, which will provide that much-needed support for households across Wales who are struggling, especially as we're expecting to see that energy price cap rise even further come January. I heard just yesterday that the average energy debt owed by people supported by Citizens Advice has almost tripled in the last few years, averaging nearly £2,000 compared to £700 in 2019. We have to break the toxic combination of high energy prices, low incomes and bad housing that is driving so much fuel poverty across Wales. So, I really want to thank the Welsh Government again for this package of support, which will make a real difference to households across Wales who need that help the most.

Finally, I want to talk about the expansion of free school meals to pupils in years 7 and 8 living in households that receive universal credit. This is also something that the Bevan Foundation has been calling for for a number of years, and I think that this is a really important change. At the moment, the income threshold for free school meals has been frozen at £7,400, which means that many families on low incomes have been missing out on that vital support. For those families, free school meals can be worth upwards of £500 a year per child, and when you're already struggling with the cost of the weekly food shop, which is going up, and household bills, which are also going up, that's a lot of money. But it's also not just about the money. We know that having access to free school meals can make a real difference to children's health and well-being, it can help them concentrate in school and also improve their educational outcomes. So, I'm also really pleased to see this extension, and I'm sure that there'll be many families across Wales who will be giving a sigh of relief to see this finally happening, especially for those who've missed out for so long because of the frozen threshold. At the end of the day, children should be able to have a decent meal at school, regardless of their family's income.

To close, Dirprwy Lywydd, I want to end where I began my contribution today. The reason I got into politics was to truly tackle child poverty and to make people's lives better. We know that times are tough—so tough for so many households across Wales, through no fault of their own. They want to see a Government that hears them, recognises their challenges and puts the measures in place to properly tackle these barriers head on. I am so glad to see that this Welsh Government has done that today in this draft budget. Diolch.

15:55

I just want to make a few contributions, if I can. Obviously, I'm trying to wade through the detail that's come through on the various spreadsheets, and I just have a few specific questions, which I think I could do with some clarity on.

I noticed that the agriculture budget looks like it's going to be cut in cash terms as well as real terms. That is a cause of concern, I think, for us on the Welsh Conservative benches, and I'd be grateful if you could clarify the rationale behind the figures that are before us. Because we are concerned that the rural economy relies very much on the farming budget and the support that it is given through the Welsh Government's farming budget, so, if you could just explain to us what the rationale behind that cut is, I'd be very grateful. We would argue that there needs to be more investment in our agricultural sector in order to maximise the benefits, given the fact that, for every pound, there's a multiplier impact that comes back into our economy. So, that cut is a concern, and as far as I can see, it's around £10 million.

In addition to that, when I've looked at the economy and enterprise budgets, clearly, I can see that there's been quite a big reduction in Business Wales and the enterprise support, but then some extra investment in the new development agency that the Welsh Government is wanting to establish. Perhaps you can just tell us a little bit more, again, about the rationale, as to why the new development agency, it would appear, is going to be given the lion's share of investment to be able to help attract inward investment and create jobs in the country. Obviously, we've been calling for some time for an arm's-length development agency, a new WDA for Wales, and it's something we want to partner with the Government to be able to achieve, but the day-to-day activity of Business Wales is clearly going to be impacted by the significant cut that's been made in its budget. I don't know whether that's just because it's a transitional arrangement to the new development agency or not, but, again, some clarity would be helpful.

Also, I note that there's been a 10 per cent reduction in the tourism and marketing budget. Again, it's very unwelcome, I think, given the fact that Wales is heavily dependent on the tourism sector. We've been talking about jobs for young people, in particular. For many people, their first job is in the tourism and hospitality industry and therefore, the ability to market that industry and Wales, as a visitor destination, is very, very important; it's very, very important to my own constituency, especially along the north Wales coast. So, I'd be very grateful to understand what the rationale for that cut is and how you anticipate that cut falling.

I want to also refer to my register of interests in relation to my role on the Reserve Forces and Cadets Association for Wales when I raise the following point, and that is Veterans' NHS Wales. It's a really important service that we've all collaborated on in this Chamber over the years. It doesn't have its own individual budget line and I have no idea where it falls within the detail of the budget, but clearly, I'm looking for assurances from you, as the finance Minister, that that is not a budget that is going to have any cuts imposed upon it. We know that the service is already facing challenges in terms of its capacity to meet the needs of the veteran community, particularly those with poor mental health and well-being. In fact, I would suggest that money invested in that budget is likely to deliver significant savings elsewhere. I noted with interest that you made reference to the £25 million fund earlier on in your opening statement, Cabinet Minister. That's the sort of fund that I would like to see investing in some of the peer mentoring services that need to run alongside Veterans’ NHS Wales to make sure that it is the holistic service that it needs to be.

My final point is on the transport section of the budget. There's a huge amount of money in there for rail support, and I can see references to the finances of Cardiff Airport as well, which appears to be gobbling more and more money each and every year. Clearly, during the scrutiny process of the budget, we'll be able to test whether those sorts of figures are appropriate. But given that the investment in that seems to be going up, I wonder to what to extent you're taking them to task for delivering value for money for the taxpayer.

16:00

I'm pleased to be here to welcome this Plaid Cymru Government's first draft budget. Welsh productivity is 15 per cent below the UK average, and that number is far too low. It's letting our people down, it's letting our businesses down, and it's letting our country down. That's why I'm glad this budget is built around this Government's mission to halve this gap within 10 years. For too long, we've been falling behind other nations and regions of the UK. It's time for a positive reset. We're all aware that the current economic climate is a difficult one. Rising inflation, global crises and funding pressures mean that we have less to work with in the immediate term. But a focused Government can still improve the economy.

Good work has already been done: thirty per cent cuts in business rates, which will give many businesses across the country breathing space; starting work on the new development agency to support and grow Welsh-owned businesses; and a national skills audit to map our future needs, to ensure our investment and direction supports where we want to go, not just papering over cracks. I'm glad to hear about more investment in the development agency and a tangible target for business growth. I'm even more glad to hear about the pilot divisions in the Valleys and rural Wales, something my constituents in Ceredigion Penfro will welcome. We know that the needs of post-industrial communities and our rural communities are different, and it's heartening that this Government is taking this seriously.

Our current situation isn't good enough. We can all agree on this. But this draft budget is a clear signal on the direction we want to take: growing Welsh-owned businesses in every corner of Wales, boosting productivity and supporting industries from the green economy, steel and advanced manufacturing. I was also pleased to hear recognition of the need to redesign the employability system. Far too many people in Wales are out of work, especially young people, who are finding it extremely difficult to find work through no fault of their own. We owe it to the people of Wales to design a system that works for them, that delivers real outcomes.

There's lots to be done, but this draft budget gives me the confidence that the foundations are being set for long-term success and that this Plaid Cymru Government will deliver the positive change people across Wales voted for. Diolch.

It is a shame to see that Reform haven't turned up once again, failing in their duty to scrutinise the Government, the job that they were elected to do. As the saying goes, 'You've got one job'. If they were here—and I'll try and make up for them, sorry, Minister; I'll try and channel them—they would no doubt call to end mini embassies or to rid the Senedd of stickers on hand dryers. These are not serious suggestions, are they? They would not improve the lives of the people of Wales.

Stay-at-home UK—sorry, Reform UK—have shown today and last week that they are not a serious party. As the Institute for Fiscal Studies noted in March, Reform's Wales manifesto did not fully face up to the fiscal realities facing the Welsh Government. But I'm glad that we have a Government that does.

One of the areas in which we have struggled in Wales, especially around funding, is transport. Five per cent of the population, 11 per cent of the infrastructure, and a mere 1 per cent of the funding. Add to this HS2 and the Oxford-Cambridge line, and we can see the difficult situation that the Government faces.

In spite of this, ensuring that we are providing £1 single bus fares and £3 day tickets for children and young people, whilst maintaining bus passes for older and disabled people at a time of intense cost-of-living pressures, is hugely welcomed and will be beneficial to so many. Providing a north-south coach service to better connect our country and investing in plans to cut congestion on the M4 are all very positive steps to fixing the foundations of our country's transport.

As others have alluded to, launching a £30 million national programme to support electric vehicles will do a huge amount to help decarbonise the economy, the absolute urgent challenge that all Governments are facing across the world. This budget is doing the work needed to build a more resilient transport system for the future. We know not everything can be achieved in the first year, but I am pleased to see the work we're already doing with an eye to the future. Diolch.

16:05

Thank you to the Minister for this budget this afternoon. As Alun said, our role is to scrutinise the Welsh Government and to make sure that those decisions are made well. But to scrutinise, you have to be present, and if you are not present, then you can't scrutinise. It is appalling that Reform are not present in the Chamber this afternoon to take up that responsibility on an historic day, namely Plaid Cymru's first budget and the first opportunity to show how we can deliver for Wales.

We have to note that the first budget, after almost 30 years of budgets from other parties, isn't going to turn things around overnight, but it does allow us to put the foundations in place for the future. I particularly welcome the focus on outcomes and on moving towards preventing problems before they arise, addressing challenges at their roots and ensuring that every pound of public spending is invested in the right places across all areas of the Government's work. Too often, we have seen public services responding after problems have become more serious, more damaging and more expensive to solve, rather than intervening at an earlier stage.

The Westminster settlement has been a reduction in real terms. This has been checked independently, but I'm glad that the new Welsh Government has made its priorities clear, and has put forward an ambitious budget where their priorities are clear. As someone who has a great interest in budgetary structures and scrutiny of the Government, as the former Chair of the Finance Committee of the Senedd, the new way of ensuring Government efficiency shows that the Plaid Cymru Government is serious about financial control.

Government efficiency relates to ensuring that Government and public services work better. I'm pleased to see the transformation fund worth £25 million to start this work—£5 million to support transformation within the Welsh Government in order to make it more effective, and £20 million for transforming public services more broadly. I also know that there are things, as we heard this afternoon, that are important to all of us, and it is therefore important that discussions are fruitful in the coming weeks, as well as meaningful and robust scrutiny.

As I said, this is a historic day with the first Plaid Cymru budget. I look forward very much to seeing how the Government delivers its programme, and to seeing many further Plaid Cymru budgets in the future. Thank you very much.

Although we are a small nation, we are a major cultural force. So, I'm delighted to see that the Government intends not only to promote culture and sport, but also to use them to build vibrant, cohesive communities, to improve health outcomes and enhance learning, as well as recognising the huge contribution that this can make to the Welsh economy and to our confidence as a nation.

We have a wonderful opportunity to show Wales to the world with the Tour de France and the Euro 2028 tournament on the horizon. I'm pleased to see investment made to deliver that, but it's also encouraging to see investment at a local level. Introducing the Nofio Ysgol programme across Wales, with £3 million in funding over the next two years, will help to increase physical activity, to engender confidence and to support preventative health. I am particularly pleased to see a minimum funding floor of 2.5 per cent for all local authorities in Wales.

In terms of other local services, I'm glad to see investment in town centres, and increasing funding available to councils to adapt their offices, schools, public libraries and leisure centres with heat pumps, solar panels and other technologies to provide low-emission heat and energy for our publicly owned buildings.

It has been said by many other people today, but I want to reiterate it, because I really feel that this budget is a positive reset following the election. I hope to see that the Plaid Cymru Government continue to deliver on the priorities of the people of Wales on which we were elected in May. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

16:10

Thank you. I call on the Cabinet Minister to reply to the debate. 

I thank Members for their contributions. 

Thank you, everybody, for your contributions this afternoon and your scrutiny. I thank Reform for giving this budget 43 per cent less scrutiny today, due to their absence, due to their decision to take another day off. As Alun Cox said, Reform UK has suddenly renamed itself Stay-at-home UK.

The Llywydd (Huw Irranca-Davies) took the Chair.

There are changes in this budget. I want to refer to some of them immediately. These are structural changes and movements within the budget because of a few changes to baselines and changes to responsibilities, and some structural changes that I will mention a little later. Darren Millar made reference in his contribution to a reduction to the agriculture budget and the tourism budget. There are explanations for some of those changes, and the scrutiny process will allow that to be highlighted. It is in the detailed documentation, and I appreciate that Members have not had an opportunity to look at that in detail yet—the detailed information that sits alongside the budget.

There are many issues that have been raised on a number of occasions by Members in this Chamber this afternoon. First of all, I will turn to ALN. The agreement on the second supplementary budget allowed, as everyone knows, the spending of an additional £60 million on ALN this year. It was one-year funding, and it was not set in the baseline for ensuing years. Within this draft budget, therefore, we are safeguarding the specific funding for ALN already in the budget, and are increasing the local government settlement in real terms, which funds our schools, which is, of course, extremely important.

But this draft budget is but the beginning of the process, and I would welcome negotiations with other parties and external organisations on how we can further develop the long-term sustainability of ALN provision. You will know that, in the second supplementary budget, we allocated £5.5 million for the development of the long-term plan in that area.

There are a few detailed issues, too. Huw Thomas referred to the changes in funding for the fire service. That moves to another part of the budget in relation to local government. And just to confirm to Lynne Neagle, in terms of mental health in schools, there is no reduction in that budget. Again, that is being transferred to a different BEL, but all of those issues will emerge to everyone during the scrutiny process.

In terms of the comments made on employability and the Milburn review today, as I said in my opening remarks, we are working with the grain of the Milburn report. That is what this Government seeks to do. The Minister has already said that strengthening the demand side should be the priority now in order to provide opportunities for young people, and that is in the spirit of what Milburn himself has said today. In this budget, we are still allocating funding for the more traditional means of supporting young people through training and support, but we need better outcomes for our young people. And we as a Government want to work positively with the Westminster Government on making our contribution here in Wales to reduce the NEET level, as it is, from 13 per cent across the UK at the moment to 5 per cent, as Milburn has mentioned today, by 2036.

I do accept the point made by Lynne Neagle on the pressure on the Medr budget. We do have some complex and important issues to address in relation to FE and HE in Wales, and the Medr budget, of course, promotes those particular aspects of work. In terms of what Lynne said about that increase in the number of students in FE and the need to see that, that is something to be welcomed, but it is also something that we need to consider in terms of its funding, and then the problems that we've heard about in some of our universities in terms of the lower levels of recruitment to our universities and the financial pressure on them. So, there will be discussion, I'm sure, as to how we can make progress to reach a position where we can fund and support these important sectors, namely FE and HE, as a Government.

To respond to the issues raised on taxation by Sam Rowlands, there will be no increase to land transaction tax in this budget, and neither will there be a reduction, as Sam wanted. So, that is the position of the budget in front of us in terms of business rates, of course. I did mention that we are looking to allocate, before the final budget, some additional funding to support businesses and to reduce business rates, and I'm very eager to discuss how we should prioritise that expenditure in the most effective way to support businesses and communities across Wales.

Many people have referred to international issues. The budget for international affairs in its entirety is now being transferred to the First Minister, and global responsibility will be a key part of the new international plan that the First Minister will publish in due course. And specifically on the Size of Wales programme and trees in Africa, this programme was due to come to an end in March 2027, but negotiations are ongoing between the Government and Size of Wales in order to take those discussions further in terms of winding the programme up.

In terms of the economic development agency that Darren Millar referred to, I can confirm that this agency will be responsible for supporting and promoting businesses—new businesses, growing businesses in Wales and those who want to come into Wales. So, in the budget for economic development and creating this new agency, there will be some work to promote and support business, which will be channelled through that new agency, and once again, there will be further details emerging during the scrutiny phase in terms of those important developments that are part of the Plaid Cymru Government's programme for government commitments. I was pleased to hear the in-principle support from the Conservatives to see this work develop further.

This is a budget of many moving parts, as I've just mentioned, and much of this is linked to the priorities of this new Government. But there are a few other large adjustments that also feature in getting us to the starting point for 2027-28, those baseline changes I've just referred to, and I'll just outline them here now. The largest of these baseline adjustments results from UK-wide reductions in employer contributions to public sector pension schemes. These changes reduce costs to public sector employers and have resulted in a reduction in our funding from the UK Government, but these reductions have been taken out of the relevant MEG baselines.

The other major baseline adjustments relate to Welsh Government staff costs. Until now, a significant part of Welsh Government staff costs have been funded from a range of programmes spread right across the budget. We're bringing all of these costs together in one place to improve the transparency about, and enhance the control over, our own Welsh Government workforce costs.

Last year, my predecessor, Mark Drakeford, set a neutral budget, providing equal inflation-matching allocations to all portfolios, and he was able to leave a substantial amount of funding unallocated at draft budget. That option was not available to us in the same way. The real-terms cut faced by this Government this year, and the need to deliver our mandate for change, required us to prioritise.

However, the decisions that we have taken in this budget still leave a sizeable pot of funding unallocated—more than the additional funding allocations that we have made to our programme for government commitments outside of health. This creates further space for further meaningful discussions with other parties over the coming weeks.

When we come to an agreement with another party, it is likely to represent the second largest budget deal in this Senedd's history. However, discussion and engagement works two ways. I was pleased this morning that four parties in this Chamber engaged with this budget's briefing this morning. Reform did not turn up or bother to answer the invite sent by this Government.

So, where this budget can be improved, I will listen and see where changes can be made. All of you will be scrutinising these plans, and good scrutiny results in better budgets. All Ministers will be discussing their own policy areas with the relevant committees, and I will certainly want to listen to the views of Senedd committees. I know that I speak on behalf of the entire Cabinet in emphasising our sincere commitment to engaging with the process fully and with the utmost transparency.

To close, I remind Members that this budget is set at a 0.5 per cent real-terms cut. This is the toughest budget settlement since the days of George Osborne. This is not the budget that I would have wanted to lay today, but it is the budget I must lay.

Room for manoeuvre in a tight budget is limited indeed. Political choices made in Westminster limit the political choices that we can make here in Wales, and for the people of Wales. One choice available to us all in this Chamber is to work together over the coming weeks to build on this draft budget, to allow our priorities to drive our decisions, and to prove the true value of partnership. Diolch yn fawr.

16:20
4. Statement by the Cabinet Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning: Update on the establishment of Unnos—A new national development body and social housing enabler

We now move on to item 4, a statement by the Cabinet Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning. I call on the Cabinet Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning, Siân Gwenllian.

Thank you very much. Llywydd, a safe, warm and affordable home is the foundation on which people build their lives. It supports good health, it gives children stability and it provides people with the security to work, participate in their communities and plan for their future. That's why this Government has committed to supporting the delivery of 20,000 additional social homes by 2030.

To meet that ambition, we will need to do things differently. Investment is essential, and I am particularly pleased about the finance Minister's important announcement this afternoon in the area of housing. But we need more than money to build homes. Across Wales, land issues, planning requirements, infrastructure constraints, viability pressures, procurement challenges and shortages of specialist skills can slow or halt good housing schemes.

Too often, the expertise that is needed to overcome those barriers is fragmented, with different partners facing the same problems independently. Unnos is our opportunity to change that. It's a new national development body and social housing enabler. It is focused relentlessly on one objective: helping Wales deliver more good-quality homes, but also more quickly.

Unnos will be an institution that solves problems and unlocks sites. It will be one that brings together expertise when sites are stalled, strengthens capacity where specialist skills are scarce and identifies solutions nationally. Most importantly, it must work alongside our delivery partners, not compete with them.

That is why we are moving forward on two fronts. We are already mobilising the Unnos programme of work, which means that the existing resources are being aligned to our principles, even while the operating model is being developed. This work includes the identification of existing sites as priorities for early intervention.

At the same time, we are developing the strategic outline case in order to determine the functions, governance and organisational form that will be most effective for Unnos in the longer term. This approach means that we are not delaying action while we design the organisation. Its form in the future must fulfil the functions Wales needs it to perform.

We have commissioned local partnerships to support programme mobilisation, support potential interventions and develop the strategic outline case and the road map. Engagement with local authorities, housing associations and other delivery partners will be a central part of this work. Their experience will help us identify where national intervention can make the difference between a scheme being stalled and homes being built.

Our initial programme will focus on land and pipeline, planning and the pre-construction period, infrastructure, finance and investment, procurement and construction capacity. We already know what we can achieve through collaboration. The Tai ar y Cyd pattern book has brought together 25 social landlords around common approaches to delivering timber-based homes that are high-performing, while the rural housing action guide and the empty homes handbook for Wales are useful tools to help to make sure that change happens.

We can learn from the Welsh Government’s own land team, which has demonstrated the value of bringing specialist expertise together where land, planning, viability or infrastructure issues can constrain development. Unnos gives us the opportunity to take those lessons further: to see the housing pipeline on a national scale, to identify barriers earlier, to share specialist expertise and to intervene where we can make the greatest difference.

I also want to be clear that Unnos’s success will be judged by what it achieves. Has it unlocked land? Has it helped stalled schemes to move into construction? Has it reduced duplication of work and strengthened our partners’ ability to deliver? And ultimately, has it helped provide more affordable homes and social homes for people and communities across Wales? Those are the tests that matter.

We have ambitious plans for housing in Wales. Delivering them requires ambition from Government too. It means being prepared to intervene, to bring together the right expertise and to find practical solutions to barriers that can hold development back. That is the ambition for Unnos. Not to replace our housing partners, but to empower them. A national body that is concentrated on delivery, not identifying problems, but helping to break them down. Our purpose is a straightforward one: to turn more opportunities into sites, more sites into homes and more homes into strong and sustainable communities. That is what I expect Unnos to help us to achieve. Thank you.

16:25

I'd like to thank the Minister for her statement today. I did have four main questions to ask the Minister about the new agency, Unnos, before the statement and they were: how much will it cost? How long will it take to establish? What is the precise remit? And is this new funding, or funding diverted from delivering new homes and ending homelessness? And I'm afraid the statement does not answer those questions. Welsh Labour's starting point is that we need to ensure decisions are taken at the most appropriate level, which, by and large, means passing them down from Welsh Government to regional and local bodies to determine. We are concerned that this proposal is moving in the wrong direction, centralising that which should be local.

Arm's-length bodies take a long time to establish. For the economic development agency, the new Plaid Cymru Welsh Government has established an expert panel, which will spend six months thinking about it, and then Ministers will presumably legislate, then set up an agency, recruit people and establish offices, so it isn't really going to be up and running until close to the end of this Senedd term. So, will the Minister take a similar approach for this agency? And if so, it does seem fair to say that the new agency isn't really going to make a contribution to building more homes in this current Senedd term.

The assumption from this Government is that a new body would be a good thing. Well, certainly, we need more capacity to make faster progress, but why does the Government think it would be better to centralise that capacity instead of continuing with developing regional capacity? Welsh Government already has a place division and is recruiting a new deputy director to head it up. That division has the remit to deliver proactive place-based approaches and made some fantastic progress in recent years. And separately, there is a more homes division, which has focused on delivering the more homes programme. Will both of those divisions be moving into the new agency? And it would be good to know if the Minister recognises that, by moving these functions into an arm's-length body, the links with other parts of Welsh Government will be weakened, creating confusion over who remains in what role for the Welsh Government and regional bodies, weakening joint working between regeneration and economic development.

It's important for housing, regeneration and economic development to go hand in hand, with site development carefully considered to ensure a mix of commercial, community and housing uses. So, creating two separate corporations for housing and development is not only expensive and centralising when we should be decentralising, it could well be disjointed, and I'd like to know what steps will be taken to guard against this.

As I've said, our belief is that local councils working together on a regional basis is the appropriate approach to delivering economic and housing development, so are Ministers intending to remove planning decisions for new towns from local and regional bodies and then hand them to this new agency? We also need to know whether this agency will be responsible for all housing development or only social housing, and what about mixed tenure developments, which are far more likely to achieve integrated, sustainable communities than a narrow focus on social housing?

Given the importance of delivering community facilities alongside housing, such as shops, schools, health centres, transport infrastructure and so on, can the Minister confirm whether the new agency will in fact be given wide-ranging powers over local communities? If these matters are to be retained by the local authority, it's very unclear why it would be appropriate to remove the housing decisions from them.

Welsh Labour's approach would be to talk to the key partners to identify what is inhibiting good housing development, and that's why we proposed establishing a new national housing taskforce to establish what needs to be done to reform the planning system so it works faster and more effectively, to reform contracting within the industry and to de-risk the types of development we want to see happen and to drive faster adoption of modern methods of construction, which, along with reforming contracting, would reduce the cost and speed things up.

That's important work, which needs to be done, but it wouldn't require the infrastructure of the arm's-length body Plaid Cymru are now planning. It wouldn't, also, need to centralise powers that rightly belong with local authorities. There is a place for commissions, consultations and working groups, but they must not replace actual delivery. So, today's statement says that the new agency's success will be judged by what it achieves. How long will it be before the Welsh Government decides whether this experiment has succeeded or failed? Diolch.

16:35

Thank you very much for your comments and, to be entirely clear, we are implementing Unnos now. The Unnos programme places a clear focus, within Government at the moment, on making swift progress towards developing the supply of social homes. Over the next six months you will see that that work will accelerate as we progress developments in all parts of Wales. We have an initial, credible pipeline of projects that are going to see the light of day gradually now over the coming months. So, the work is happening, and the work that needs to be done to unlock that potential and to eradicate some of the barriers, some of that is happening.

But the focus needs to be far clearer and we need to accelerate the pace of work so that we do realise and achieve the target that we've set for ourselves of 20,000 new social homes before the end of this Senedd term. And within the next 12 months, the aim is to complete the business case and the recommendations that we will need as Ministers to make decisions on Unnos for the future. So, there are two things happening. We have Unnos, we have a full programme that is driving things forward. We have to accelerate that, and that is the work that is happening alongside it to see what exactly the best structure would be for the purpose that we have here. We share that purpose: we want to see more affordable homes for people, because we know how important safe homes are for people in their communities. So, the ambition is clear: to deliver Unnos now; to show the practical progress over the next months; and to be in a situation to make the key decisions on a longer term model within 12 months.

You asked about centralisation and avoiding duplication and so on. Well, of course, the implementation will still take place on the county council level, housing association level, on a regional level, and a local level. We won't intervene in the planning system. Local housing assessments feed into the planning process that shows, in the local development plans, what the need for homes is and in what location, and so that isn't part of the package. But we are going to be able to use Unnos to see what the barriers are in terms of planning within some developments in future, and how we can get everyone together to ensure the developments happen in a timely manner.

You also asked about the link with the national development agency. Clearly, the work now in developing the outline business case for Unnos will happen in alignment with the work of the Minister for economy, and we will need to see exactly how the interrelationship between the two bodies will develop to maximise the benefits.

Thank you, Cabinet Minister, for today's statement. I do not think anyone in this Chamber would oppose measures intended to increase the supply of affordable and social housing. Wales is in the middle of a housing crisis. Waiting lists continue to grow, temporary accommodation costs are spiralling, and too many families remain unable to access a suitable home. Now, the proposal for Unnos appears similar to calls from my own party for a stronger dedicated body to drive development and housing delivery, but falls short of our commitment to re-establishing a Welsh development agency to unlock growth and investment. However, the real question is not whether we create another organisation; the real question is whether it will actually build homes.

Now, most local authorities have transferred their housing stock to registered social landlords over many years, yet, despite that change, we remain still desperately short of homes to allocate. The housing sector itself has repeatedly warned that the Welsh Government's target of 20,000 new social homes is highly challenging without significant reforms to land planning process and delivery mechanisms. Unnos is described as a body to assist with land acquisition, planning, project management and procurement. Cabinet Minister, can you explain what difference this body will make in practice? How do you envisage it speeding up planning decisions, especially when you've said that they won't actually be getting involved with the local authority planning system? We know that is controlled by local government, and, when that's a barrier in the hands of local government, how are you going to accelerate or remove some of the barriers in place? We need to do things that stop associations and councils from getting the spades in the ground, or we will simply add another layer of administration between decision makers and delivery.

Wales does not suffer from a shortage of strategies, announcements and quangos. What Wales suffers from is a shortage of homes. If the Government believes Unnos is the answer, it must set out clearly how success will be measured, what targets will be attached to it, and what happens if those targets are not met. The Welsh Conservatives have consistently argued that we need more homes of all tenures, a more efficient planning system, an infrastructure-first approach to development, and incentives to ensure housing projects are delivered quickly.

So, I ask the Cabinet Minister: does she agree that fast-tracking affordable housing developments and improving the efficiency of the planning system are fundamental if we are to meet housing need in Wales? We need reassurance across the Chamber that Unnos will be judged not by the number of meetings it holds or the reports it will publish, but by one simple measure—what it delivers, the homes that Welsh families desperately need. If Unnos helps build homes faster, we will welcome that. But if it becomes yet another navel-gazing quango, consuming resources without improving delivery, it will have failed the very people it was created to help. 

16:40

Thank you very much. I agree with you on that point. This isn't another quango; in fact, it's not a quango at all—that's not the purpose of looking at a strategic outline case for Unnos. The whole point is to build more warm, affordable and safe homes for our people. I agree with you that that will be the measure of success of Unnos. At the moment, we have a pipeline of homes in the system that is robust, but we aren't going to deliver our objectives as a Government. We want to see an end to homelessness, we want to see an end to people living in temporary accommodation, and we want to bring waiting lists for social housing right down. So, those will be the criteria as to whether we will have succeeded or not in the future.

You do have to have momentum within an arm's-length body. There are so many benefits that will emerge, hopefully, as the outline strategic case is drawn together. There are possible functions for Unnos: identifying land, brokerage, procuring and de-risking sites, planning, project management, and pre-construction support. And in terms of planning, of course the planning decisions will be taken according to the usual procedures, but, having identified a site, having brought everyone around the table sooner in the planning process, then surely we will be able to reach a planning decision so much earlier, and then we will be able to progress the project and create homes for our people.

Now, other possible functions: co-ordination on infrastructure and enabling work in terms of infrastructure. Because infrastructure—. You often see problems in terms of water infrastructure, sewerage, and so on, and those kinds of issues can hold projects back. So, we need to put a clear focus on the site and the unlocking work that needs to take place before a development can proceed.

Funding and investment: now, I see this as a very important role for Unnos—facilitating access to funding and investment. The grants won't be sufficient to deliver what we want to deliver; we have to find innovative ways of bringing new funding and investment into this sector. Procurement support and links between projects, contractors, suppliers and service providers: looking nationally to ensure that co-operation can happen more effectively between contractors and suppliers and to create those supply chains, and so on and so forth. There are a number of other possible functions that we could consider.

Now, as you say, if Unnos enables us to facilitate the provision of more homes and to do that more swiftly, then that can only be a good thing, can't it? And you've welcomed that. So, I hope that you will see that that is the purpose of this Government—to drive that forward. And I look forward to having further constructive discussions with you on this whole programme. Thank you.

16:45

As a member of the Local Government, Housing and Planning Committee, it has become clear to me that there are major challenges facing the housing sector across Wales, therefore, using Unnos as a catalyst for social housing is to be welcomed. During our recent inquiry into vacant properties, it was clear that processes in the sector continue to be complex and confused, so I hope that Unnos will be able to help to address those factors.

A challenge in my constituency—and it's very disappointing that the Members of Reform representing Brycheiniog Tawe Nedd aren't in the Chamber today—but a challenge in my constituency, and I'm sure across the whole of Wales, is attracting contractors to work in more rural areas—again, an example of the inequity between urban and rural areas. Would the Cabinet Minister outline how Unnos could be deployed to ensure that companies bid for construction opportunities in rural and urban areas, thereby ensuring that rural areas aren't left behind once again? Thank you.

Thank you very much. You used the term 'enabler', and that is the founding principle of Unnos—to enable developments to take place, to be that enabler turning vacant properties into social housing to support rural areas that need different models to more urban areas. And, certainly, Unnos can help to ensure that rural areas are not left behind by adopting a more strategic approach of dealing with the housing pipeline across Wales. By bringing housing associations, the local authorities and the construction sector together, contractors will be able to see where the work exists and what's in the pipeline, and Unnos will help to co-ordinate programmes so that smaller rural developments are part of a viable pipeline for investment, along with urban developments. So, you can think of it as a package—something of a greater scale in an urban area, but something smaller happening in a rural area, but that they would be interconnected and that the contractors would work together and the  supply chains could also work for the benefit of both developments. So, thank you for your question. I do truly believe that Unnos has a particular role to play in terms of our rural areas, but it will do that along with the efforts of rural communities and where the Welsh language is very strong, the communities could lead on housing developments in those areas. And there are wonderful examples of communities that have innovated in that regard, and that needs to happen alongside Unnos and, certainly, rural areas do need a particular emphasis in this area. 

16:50

The shortage of skilled workers is likely to be a major challenge if the Government is to meet its target of 20,000 new social homes by the end of this Senedd. Recent research for the Welsh Government suggests that a huge opportunity is being missed for jobs supporting the green transition, through a lack of investment in training and skills. The report said that there was already a shortfall of 3,400 workers in 2026 and a projected shortfall of 57,000 workers by 2035.

There is a serious shortage of green skills within the Welsh construction workforce. We need builders, plumbers and electricians ready to fit heat pumps, solar panels, batteries and insulation in every home in order to reach net zero and bring down household energy bills. So, Gweinidog, what role can Unnos play in growing and upskilling the green construction workforce to ensure that Cymru meets its climate targets, keeps heating costs down and supports workers to benefit from the significant opportunities for building new, sustainable homes and retrofitting existing homes?

Thank you very much for that question. Skills are vital, and there's a genuine opportunity here, isn't there, in Wales, for us to be upskilling our young people, upskilling our current craftspeople in modern methods of constructing homes that are energy efficient, but also to retrofit the properties that we currently have. And certainly, this is one of the work streams that Unnos will be focusing on, because it can be a barrier at the moment in terms of developing the new estates or retrofitting empty properties. A lack of skills is a problem. So, I have been having discussions with the Deputy Minister for Skills and Tertiary Education, emphasising this genuine opportunity that there is in this specific area.

We are at risk of losing people who have been trained to do this retrofitting work. The ECO4 scheme of the UK Government came to an end very abruptly, didn't it, and I am concerned that we are going to lose very highly skilled workers. But I am determined, through Unnos, but also through the retrofit programme that this Government has—and hopefully you will have seen in the budget that it is receiving a significant boost, not just in terms of new social homes, but retrofitting as well—that there is an opportunity. I agree entirely with you, and we do have to place that emphasis and take that opportunity. 

Diolch, Lywydd. Diolch for the statement today. I welcome the progress being made towards establishing Unnos and a commitment by this Government to increase the supply of social housing.

In Cardiff, in my constituency, we regularly see the consequences of the housing shortage through casework. Currently, my office is supporting a mother living in a one-bedroomed property with her 16-year-old son and a 13-month-old daughter. The children are sharing one bedroom while the mother sleeps in the living room. And I have concerns around this, not only for the mental well-being of the family, but also for the development of the children, particularly the 13-month-old.

My team have also heard from constituents facing homelessness after being told they could no longer remain in overcrowded family accommodation. And despite working and doing everything they could do to find housing, they were unable to afford the private rental sector and were left relying on homelessness support. These are not isolated cases. Housing is one of the most prominent things constituents contact my office about, and this reflects the reality facing so many families across Cardiff, and demonstrates why increasing the supply of social housing is so important. So, I wonder how the Welsh Government will ensure that Unnos helps increase the supply of social housing in those communities that are experiencing the most pressure.

16:55

Thank you very much. Unnos really must focus on where the need for housing exists and the right sorts of housing, and not just where it is easy to build and where it makes financial sense to build, but doesn't necessarily meet the exact needs that you set out in your question. So, I do think that Unnos could provide that clear focus on developing housing where the need is at its greatest, working with local authorities and with housing associations, and using the evidence that's already out there through the work undertaken as part of the local housing assessment. So, it is responding to that need.

And I will conclude just by saying that we do have to think what the outcomes we are seeking are. We shouldn't be thinking about governance or how many projects the body will be involved with, but will we have fewer people in the position that you describe, fewer families in temporary accommodation, less time for people to have to wait for appropriate housing, fewer families in spaces that are too small for them, and a reduction in homelessness. If we can say 'Yes, we have delivered on those objectives', then that will prove the value of Unnos. 

5. Statement by the Cabinet Minister for Health and Care: Emergency and Acute Care Wales

We'll move now to our next item, a statement by the Cabinet Minister for Health and Care: Emergency and Acute Care Wales. I call on the Cabinet Minister—Mabon ap Gwynfor. 

Thank you very much, Llywydd. Today, I am launching Emergency and Acute Care Wales, which is our national policy framework for people who become seriously ill or injured, whose condition deteriorates, or who need specialist hospital care. This framework marks an important early step in delivering our programme for government. It sets a clear direction for better emergency and acute care across Wales. This policy framework's ambition is straightforward: implementing Community by Design principles, moving from emergency care to recovery where needed, and spending only the clinically necessary time in hospital.

Our services face significant pressure. Behind the reports of ambulance delays, prolonged emergency department waits and patients receiving care in corridors are people, families and carers experiencing distress and avoidable harms. People living with frailty or dementia, those approaching the end of life, and others with additional vulnerabilities can be particularly affected.

For an older or frail person, unnecessary time spent in hospital can mean losing mobility, independence and confidence. This framework aims to prevent that harm, protecting dignity and supporting recovery, not simply moving people through hospital faster. For people in Wales, the commitment is clear, namely a rapid response when the condition is serious; receiving the right specialist care without unnecessary transfers or repeated assessments; and a safe return home, seven days a week, with the medicines, rehabilitation support and the additional support that you need.

So, what will be different? The difference is in the way we deliver: one connected pathway, organised around the person, with annual milestones, clear organisational responsibilities, and public reporting of progress. Issues with ambulance response, emergency departments, hospital flow and discharge must be improved together, rather than treated as separate problems.

The framework forms part of Community by Design—organising health and care around people, rather than institutions. That model supports prevention, earlier intervention and care closer to home. This framework connects it to emergency response, and specialist treatment and recovery when hospital expertise is needed. The framework’s first guiding principle is rapid access to emergency and time-critical care. People with life-threatening illness, serious injury or rapid deterioration must be identified quickly. Clinical need must determine the response they receive, not where they live or how they enter the system.

An emergency department should not be a compulsory stopping point on every emergency journey. Where clinical needs are clear and direct access is safe and appropriate, we want people to reach specialist expertise straight away, whether stroke care, specialist acute care or another time-critical service. Life-saving care also begins in our community. By 2029, I want Wales to become a nation of lifesavers, with more people knowing how to respond to cardiac arrest, and interventions starting sooner. We will explore how technology, including drone-delivered defibrillators, could improve survival.

The second guiding principle is safe transition from hospital to home. We want to fundamentally change the first 72 hours of hospital care: rapid assessment, diagnosis and treatment, with support for recovery and planning for home beginning as soon as someone arrives. Where clinically appropriate, many more people should receive the care they need and return home on the same day or within 72 hours. This is not a 72-hour discharge target, nor is it about sending people home before they are ready. It means earlier decisions by experienced clinicians and timely care, so people don't remain in hospital because the system hasn't moved quickly enough. Where longer stays are needed, every additional day must add clinical value. 

Publishing a framework is not the same as improving care. Delivery must be measurable and accountable. To drive forward delivery, we have set annual milestones from 2027, with a formal review in 2030, on the route to our 2034 ambition. We’ve commissioned NHS Wales Performance and Improvement to develop implementation and improvement support plans with NHS Wales and partners. These will set clear responsibilities for each organisation. We've made up to £23.3 million available from 2027-28 to support delivery of the framework, including £18.3 million in protected funding for health boards. Organisations will be expected to demonstrate how this investment translates into measurable improvements for people. And we've begun developing measures to show where we are starting from and track reductions in corridor care, avoidable delay and unnecessary hospital stays. This work will conclude by March 2027. I'll update Members before implementation begins, in April 2027. We'll report publicly each year on progress, where delivery is falling short, and action to get back on track. Health boards will also be required to publish more local progress data.

Llywydd, I don't accept corridor care as an inevitable feature of a busy NHS. Care that compromises privacy, dignity or safety must not become accepted practice. Our ambition is to eliminate corridor care as a routine response to operational pressure by 2029. I've established a national NHS Wales corridor care action group to agree consistent definitions, measurement and reporting, and minimum safeguards where corridor care occurs.

This is not about defining an acceptable level of corridor care. Steps to measure performance must strengthen accountability alongside reliable delivery of the principles of Community by Design, and this framework. Better information is essential to that accountability. We have strengthened emergency department waiting time reporting by removing clinical exceptions. This makes people's actual waits more transparent.

We will judge success not just by activity or waiting times, but also by monitoring whether people survive, recover, retain their independence, receive equitable care and spend only the clinically necessary time in hospital. We will roll out the Welsh emergency care dataset, which will give us better information about demand, how seriously ill people are, their treatment, their journey through care and their outcomes. Aneurin Bevan University Health Board will lead the work of early deployment, testing more meaningful measures before the dataset's national implementation.

To conclude, I thank our NHS and care staff for their skill, their compassion and their commitment under pressure. We have listened to them, and we must give them the conditions to deliver by making timely decisions, promoting effective joint working and having a clear focus on patients.

Llywydd, our ambition is clear: delivering the Community by Design principles, moving from emergency care to recovery where needed, and spending only the clinically necessary time in hospital. The test of success is whether people receive the care they need sooner, retain their independence and recover safety at home. That is the difference that this framework must make.

17:05

I thank the Cabinet Minister for his statement today. Let me begin by recognising the extraordinary work of those NHS staff working across our urgent and emergency care services. They are doing so in exceptionally difficult circumstances, often under immense pressure and with a level of commitment and compassion that patients and their families rightly appreciate.

But we must be honest about the experience of too many patients. Too many people are waiting for hours, even days, in emergency departments, sometimes in corridors or inappropriate clinical spaces, in circumstances that are distressing for patients and staff alike. Nobody should feel anxious about becoming ill because they fear what might happen when they arrive at hospital. We know that overcrowded emergency departments are often the symptom of wider pressures elsewhere in the system, particularly delays in discharge, shortages in social care and difficulties accessing community and out-of-hours services. But recognising those pressures must never become an excuse for accepting the unacceptable.

Llywydd, we are not where we need to be, so it's welcome that the Minister has turned his attention to the challenges within emergency and acute care. However, six months into this Plaid Cymru Government, patients have yet to see improvement in the measures that matter the most. More people are waiting over 12 hours in emergency departments, four-hour performance has deteriorated and response times for the most serious emergency calls are longer than when Welsh Labour left office. That deterioration cannot simply be explained away by higher demand. In May, emergency departments saw just over 98,100 attendances. In September, the figure was just over 98,700. So, why has performance deteriorated since May? Why are patients seeing worse results today than they were in the spring?

The people of Wales are entitled to ask when the ambitions set out in this new framework will translate into real improvements in front-line services. The Minister has set out annual milestones and a long-term ambition to 2034, but patients waiting in emergency departments today will want to know what will change for them before then. Twenty-three million pounds has been announced to support delivery from 2027-28, but given the scale of the pressures currently facing emergency departments, what action will be taken between now and April 2027 to reduce corridor care, improve patient flow and support front-line services? Patients will want to know what help is coming now, not simply what is planned for the future.

The Minister presents Emergency and Acute Care Wales as a new national framework. However, many of its stated ambitions, including earlier intervention, avoiding unnecessary admissions, improving discharge and reducing delays, are objectives that have already featured in previous urgent and emergency care plans. So, what specifically is different about this framework? What practical changes in clinical practice, in capacity, in patient flow or accountability will distinguish it from the six goals programme and other existing initiatives? And, most importantly, when will patients and staff begin to see that difference in practice?

We know that patients can't move through emergency departments if beds are occupied by people who are ready to leave hospital but cannot access care and support when they need to be in the community. We also know that improving access to primary care, community services and out-of-hours provision is essential if we are to prevent avoidable attendances in the first place. Llywydd, the ultimate test is not whether a framework is published, it's whether patients spend less time waiting in emergency departments, whether corridor care is reduced, whether discharge happens more quickly, and whether people experience better care. Patients and staff will judge this framework not by its aspirations, but by its results, and that is the standard against which the Government must now be held accountable. Diolch.

17:10

May I start by thanking the Member for those comments and by echoing his comments at the outset in relation to the hard work of the workforce in our acute and A&E departments, who are working in very difficult conditions? I also recognise their contribution and thank them for their work. 

The Member is absolutely right that the experience of patients going into ED care or into acute settings isn't what it should be. It's part of the legacy that we have inherited, if we are being honest about it. It's a series of waits that they are having to go through at the moment. They either wait for an ambulance, or wait in an ambulance for discharge, or wait in an ED department, or wait in a corridor, or wait in a bed for discharge. It's waiting—that is the experience of people—without knowing when they should expect the care, where they should expect the care, and when they can expect improvement.

To answer one of the final questions that you asked, namely what is different about this, what is different is that we are looking at the whole pathway. From the initial stage, when someone either phones for an ambulance or enters an ED, to that discharge, they can expect a better flow, a better response and a better understanding of what care they should receive and where they should receive it, at an earlier stage, rather than, previously—. And this isn't being overly critical of previous Governments. Previous Governments have tried different techniques, which haven't succeeded. I am sure that we'd agree on that. But the various techniques of the previous Government were to look at individual parts of the pathway—either the ambulance, or the discharge, or the ED. We are looking at the whole, because we can't manage one without managing the whole of it. Each part of the chain impacts on the other. So, that's the difference that we have in this respect.

We are also setting out clearly that we expect patients to know what is expected of their care within 72 hours. Where clinically appropriate, patients will leave as soon as possible from hospital, because we know that patients will get better care and improve quicker if they are home, or closer to home, than if they stay unnecessarily in a hospital. We are publishing the framework now, so that health boards and delivery partners are able to implement it and include it as part of their plans, whether it is looking at the workforce, preparation of workforce decisions, allocating resources, planning for the next year ahead—so that they can do that from 1 April. That's why we are introducing it now, but we expect them to start working on it immediately.

You are absolutely right that the stated ambitions—. While it is all well and good for any politician to stand up and say warm words and say, 'This is what we want to happen', we will be judged on delivery. I expect health boards to work with us to deliver on this. That is why I have made it clear that we expect corridor care to be eliminated by 2029. That is one of the targets. We will be working on the other targets before that 1 April deadline, so that they can work with us to make sure that people see the improvements that you have demanded, that I am demanding, and that I am sure the whole Senedd is in agreement on.

Could I thank the Cabinet Minister for this afternoon's statement, although I am a bit disappointed that the details of this plan were announced in the press first before sharing it here in the Senedd today? Let's not beat around the bush. Our health service is in a dire state. It has been for quite some time, and things do not appear to be getting any better, sadly. To be clear, that is not a reflection, in any way, shape or form, of our hard-working and dedicated NHS staff, who go above and beyond. It is down to successive Government failures here in Wales.

The aims of this plan, to deliver faster emergency care and help people return home sooner, are things that we all undoubtedly want to see. This afternoon's statement seems to be full of things that the Welsh Government want to do, but it is very scarce on how it is going to be delivered. Simply saying something does not make it magically happen, Cabinet Minister.

You have clearly got ambition, but how exactly is that going to work in reality, when our health boards are already under immense pressure? How are you going to make sure that this ambition is turned into tangible action that benefits patients? And by when, Cabinet Minister? I know that you mentioned 2029, but I notice that the details on timelines and targets are also missing from this plan. You say that milestones have been set. What exactly are those milestones? And are you confident that the funding announcement today will be enough to achieve this, Cabinet Minister?

I'm sure that you have heard the truly shocking story of the 81-year-old woman with terminal cancer who was left in a storeroom at the Royal Gwent Hospital in Newport for 40 hours after having chemotherapy. Pam Smith was forced to push a number of chairs together to create a makeshift bed, because no proper beds were available for her. Pam, who has been told that this Christmas could be her last, said she felt abandoned by the NHS. I'm sure you'll agree, Cabinet Minister, that it is frankly unacceptable that incidents like this are indeed taking place within our hospitals. It's just shocking.

Eliminating corridor care is apparently an aim of this emergency and acute care plan, which, again, is laudable, but I want detail. What steps is this Government going to be taking to ensure someone doesn't have to endure what Pam did when seeking care? This Government has made commitments previously about bringing corridor care to an end, and I really do welcome that, because it's incredibly dangerous and, frankly, inhumane. But words are just not enough, Cabinet Minister, and I'm not convinced the Government truly understands the sheer scale of the problem.

We still do not have a comprehensive national data plan being published, or, in fact, any stats with that telling us how many patients are experiencing corridor care across Wales. Cabinet Minister, how can a Government truly move forward in eliminating corridor care when we do not know the exact number of patients being affected by this? The Government says that it wants to eliminate corridor care by 2029. What happens if it's not achieved by then, Cabinet Minister? Who's going to be on the firing line?

For a Government determined to deliver faster emergency care, I'm surprised that there was little mention from the Cabinet Minister about ambulances. Only last week we heard the truly tragic cases of two women who died after falling at home and waiting for hours on end for help to arrive. In both of these separate cases, emergency services took between 17 to 24 hours from the original 999 calls to arrive. The senior coroner from north Wales has warned that there is a risk of further deaths happening if no action is taken. I'm sure, like me, the Cabinet Minister really does not want to see that happen again. So, what action is being taken in light of the coroner's warning?

Cabinet Minister, ambulance handover delays remain a significant challenge, putting patients at risk and preventing paramedics from responding to emergency calls. Just a few weeks ago, the Welsh Conservative research team uncovered that the Welsh ambulance service staff have worked almost 4 million hours of overtime since April 2017. That's over 36,000 extra hours every single month, costing the NHS well over £100 million. This is an ambulance service that, whilst doing incredible work, is extremely overstretched and under-resourced. They are supposed to be a part of the solution to improving emergency care, yet they haven't had a single mention today.

According to a damning Audit Wales investigation, only one in five patients were handed over within the target 15-minute window. Last year, more than 15,000 patients waited more than four hours to be handed over. Again, Cabinet Minister, I was concerned that you made no reference to A&E departments in this statement, given the vital role that they play. The latest NHS figures show that more than 98,700 people attended emergency departments across Wales in just one month alone. That's the second highest figure on record. Out of all of those who attended A&E, only 63.9 per cent of them were admitted, transferred or discharged within the four-hour target, and nearly 12,000 of them waited more than 12 hours to be seen. That's simply not sustainable, Cabinet Minister. So, how is the Government going to turn this around? And again, can we get a timescale as to when we can expect to see these improvements?

Presiding Officer, Plaid Cymru came into Government promising change. The party has been in office for six months now. We've heard what the Government intends to do. Now we need to see you actually deliver on those pledges. Thank you.

of the 81-year-old woman with terminal cancer who was left in a storeroom at the Royal Gwent Hospital in Newport for 40 hours after having chemotherapy. Pam Smith was forced to push a number of chairs together to create a makeshift bed, because no proper beds were available for her. Pam, who has been told that this Christmas could be her last, said she felt abandoned by the NHS. I'm sure you'll agree, Cabinet Minister, that this is frankly unacceptable, that incidents like this are indeed taking place within our hospitals. It's just shocking.

Eliminating corridor care is apparently an aim of this emergency and acute care plan, which, again, is laudable, but I want detail. What steps is this Government going to be taking to ensure someone doesn't have to endure what Pam did when seeking care? This Government has made commitments previously about bringing corridor care to an end, and I really do welcome that, because it's incredibly dangerous and, frankly, inhumane. But words are just not enough, Cabinet Minister, and I'm not convinced the Government truly understands the sheer scale of the problem.

We still do not have a comprehensive national data plan being published, or, in fact, any stats with that telling us how many patients are experiencing corridor care across Wales. Cabinet Minister, how can a Government truly move forward in eliminating corridor care when we do not know the exact number of patients being affected by this? The Government says that it wants to eliminate corridor care by 2029. What happens if it's not achieved by then, Cabinet Minister? Who's going to be on the firing line?

For a Government determined to deliver faster emergency care, I'm surprised that there was little mention from the Cabinet Minister about ambulances. Only last week, we heard the truly tragic cases of two women who died after falling at home and waiting for hours on end for help to arrive. In both of these separate cases, emergency services took between 17 to 24 hours from the original 999 calls to arrive. The senior coroner from north Wales has warned that there is a risk of further deaths happening if no action is taken. I'm sure, like me, the Cabinet Minister really does not want to see that happen again. So, what action is being taken in light of the coroner's warning?

Cabinet Minister, ambulance handover delays remain a significant challenge, putting patients at risk and preventing paramedics from responding to emergency calls. Just a few weeks ago, the Welsh Conservative research team uncovered that the Welsh ambulance service staff have worked almost 4 million hours of overtime since April 2017. That's over 36,000 extra hours every single month, costing the NHS well over £100 million. This is an ambulance service that, whilst doing incredible work, is extremely overstretched and under-resourced. They are supposed to be a part of the solution to improving emergency care, yet they haven't had a single mention today.

According to a damning Audit Wales investigation, only one in five patients were handed over within the target 15-minute window. Last year, more than 15,000 patients waited more than four hours to be handed over.

Again, Cabinet Minister, I was concerned that you made no reference to A&E departments in this statement, given the vital role that they play. The latest NHS figures show that more than 98,700 people attended emergency departments across Wales in just one month alone. That's the second highest figure on record. Out of all of those who attended A&E, only 63.9 per cent of them were admitted, transferred or discharged within the four-hour target, and nearly 12,000 of them waited more than 12 hours to be seen. That's simply not sustainable, Cabinet Minister. So how is the Government going to turn this around? And again, can we get a timescale as to when we can expect to see these improvements?

Presiding Officer, Plaid Cymru came into Government promising change. The party has been in office for six months now. We've heard what the Government intends to do. Now we need to see you actually deliver on those pledges. Thank you.

17:15

May I thank the Member for those comments? She expresses her disappointment that she'd heard about some of the comments or the intentions ahead of time. I would hope that she would welcome the fact that I am willing to go public, to be scrutinised publicly, so that people understand what we're doing, being transparent with our plans. That's the intention, and this is an opportunity for the Member to ask those questions too, to be able to scrutinise and to ensure that we are held to account.

Now, the Member can't have it both ways. You can't, on the one hand, like you did at the end there, say, 'Look, you've been in power for six months and you've not delivered anything', and say you don't think that we understand the scale of the problem, it's a massive issue that we are facing. It's either one or the other, and it's that final one. It is a massive issue that we're facing, and it is going to take time to turn the Titanic around, to make sure that we shift things, move things and improve things.

You're right, there is no data, and that's why we are starting the process now of defining what corridor care is, because if you can't define what it is, you can't collect the data to identify the problem. So, you need that definition. That's what we're doing now, that's why I've convened that corridor care action group together in order to start that process and have that clear definition, knowing what the problem is, where the problem lies. And then once you identify it, you can get the health boards to develop the workforce plans that they have, rearrange the clinical plans that they have

rearrange the clinical plans that they have for their hospitals, and make sure that corridor care is eliminated by 2029. That's something that the previous Government refused to do; they refused to define what corridor care was; they refused to dedicate themselves to eliminating it. We are committed to doing that.

You asked about ambulances, and you mentioned that there was no mention of ambulances. I just kindly suggest that if you look back on the Record, and find that about two minutes into my contribution, I talked about ambulances. And the whole plan is around exactly from that point where someone phones an ambulance or enters hospital via an ambulance, through to discharge at the end. So, it looks at the whole pathway.

And, you know, if you ask me to talk more about ambulances or mention more about corridor care or mention more about delayed discharges, that's the problem of the previous plans was they were all focusing on one individual part rather than that pathway, and that's why I'm talking here about the whole pathway, instead of concentrating on the one part. We know what the problems are—you did very well, and I agree with your thesis on listing the problems—we know what the problems are. I've identified the problems, and now I'm identifying the solution, and this is the solution. Judge me on the delivery of this when the time comes.

17:20

I'd like to note how Reform have decided not to turn up to this debate on our emergency and acute care.

I fully welcome this statement. We need a more people-centred system. Emergency care is about more than just what happens in an emergency department, or indeed hospitals. If we are serious about ending corridor care and reducing delays, we need every part of the system working together around the needs of the patient. 

Change is needed not only in the NHS but also to prevent emergencies and help people recover at home. That's why I was so pleased today to hear about the preventative investment into safe and warm homes. It's clear to me that current services in Hywel Dda have not been co-designed with patients and do not reflect people's lived experience; in particular, the reality of long distances and poor transport, which means that people cannot get to the services they need, which is often hugely distressing. So, Minister, how will you ensure that people across Wales benefit from the positive vision you've outlined today? Diolch.

Llywydd, can I start in response to the opening comments by the Member? I've been scrutinised now and challenged by the leader of the Labour Party, by the spokesperson for the Conservatives, and they've been good questions. They've been fair, legitimate questions, and I know that you'll be holding me to account for the responses I've given you over the coming months and years. That's the role of elected Members of this Chamber, and I'm sure that the public out there will thank you for those challenges, and it will mean that I will be going back to officials, going back to my department and making sure, 'Look, we need to make sure that these issues are responded to as we move forward.' That's our role.

It's shameful that Reform aren't here to carry out their duties. The people who voted for them would have expected them to challenge me and to scrutinise me; they're not here. I thought that they were interested in corridor care, in ambulance waiting times, in discharges of patients from hospital. They're clearly not interested in the wellbeing and health of our nation.

To the substantive question that the Member raised, the Member is right that geography matters, but geography mustn't become a determinant of outcome. The framework is explicit. People with time-critical conditions should reach the right specialist service as quickly as possible, while more care should be available at home or in local communities when hospital isn't required.

So, I'll judge proposals in Hywel Dda, as elsewhere in Wales, against outcomes for people, not simply where buildings are located. The test is whether someone living in rural Ceredigion or Pembrokeshire can access the right clinical response at the right time and achieve an equitable outcome. That is what patient-centred care means in practice.

Diolch, Llywydd. Cabinet Minister, your statement rightly says that people with life-threatening illness, serious injury or rapid deterioration must be identified quickly, but unfortunately, that's not happening for many people in my constituency.

Last week I raised the case of Mr Lambert, an 85-year-old constituent of mine who waited for an ambulance

waited for an ambulance for over 16 hours following a fall he had at his home. Now, your statement makes it clear that the emergency and acute care policy framework's first guiding principle is rapid access to emergency and time-critical care, and ambulance services are a critical part of the emergency care system. Now, in my view, there is an urgent need for greater investment in ambulance services to ensure they are equipped to meet the needs of rural communities, particularly because geography and longer travel times can also have an impact on response times. Therefore, can you provide an update on the discussions that you've had with the Welsh Ambulance Services NHS Trust about this framework? And can you also tell us what additional support or investment is being provided to strengthen ambulance services in west Wales so that people like Mr Lambert and indeed others do not have to wait 16 hours for an ambulance in the future? 

17:25

I'd like to thank the Member for those comments. He referenced the story of Mr Lambert. I read that story in the newspaper, and I was sorry to hear of his experiences. It's not an experience that someone should expect. It's not something that we expect. I also was remiss not to mention the case study raised by Natasha as well, which is an experience we don't expect to see in our hospitals. Patients shouldn't expect that. We need to see improvement. That's why we're putting this framework into work now.

So, I'd be interested in the discussion around the funding of WAST and ambulances. As it stands, it seems, from where I'm standing, that it's not an issue of funding or resources within the Wales ambulance service. We could have more ambulances and more paramedics and more ambulance drivers in those ambulances, but where would they be? They'd still be waiting outside a hospital, queuing to discharge the patient into the hospital. It's a case, then, where we need those ambulances that are queuing up outside the hospitals back out on the road to meet the demands of the community, making sure that those purple calls, those red and amber calls are met as soon as possible. That's why we've got this framework in place, exactly for that purpose, to make sure that we discharge patients from the ambulance as they go into hospital and move people, move that flow of people through a hospital quicker so that they reach the appropriate place for the appropriate care that they need for their improved clinical outcomes rather than having people wait for ambulances, which is the conclusion and the result of the problems that we are currently finding ourselves in. So you're quite right to identify the current problems that we've got. That's what we're trying to fix now.

With regard to greater investment, we are putting £23 million into this, £18 million into the health boards, and then the other amount going into the various trusts and organisations that we have in order to deliver on this, making sure that they have the resources in order to move services around to accommodate the new expectations that we have.

Minister, the Stroke Association recently hosted an event here in the Neuadd, where the top clinicians in Wales discussed how best an all-Wales service could be structured. At present, it's no secret that stroke care in our country is patchy, unreliable and extremely variable. However, the clinicians were united that everyone in our nation needs access to an urgent thrombectomy service in the event of an acute stroke. Clinicians should be listened to. No health board in Wales currently provides the service 24 hours, seven days a week. Whilst our small nation has so many small health boards, each with entrenched boundaries, solving these problems within each health board is very, very difficult. How is the Minister planning to ensure that everyone in our nation has access to this service at any time of day or night and as soon as possible?

Diolch i John. Thank you for that question. Can I also thank Dr Gwyn Williams as well for working with you on this question and the work that he's done with you behind the scenes on this? I understand that he can't be present today because he's been called out on urgent business, and I thank him for that. Can I also, if you'll indulge me, Dirprwy Lywydd, wish the Member pen-blwydd hapus today,

with the Member pen-blwydd hapus today, on the same day as my son? So, pen-blwydd hapus, John.

Stroke is a programme for government priority. Work starts now, overseen by the national clinical services plan oversight board, and I look forward to seeing more detailed plans in due course outlining how service transformation will improve stroke outcomes for people in Wales. We're committed to better care for people with complex and long-term conditions, earlier diagnosis, and faster, safe, high-quality treatment across Wales. Our updated 2026 quality statement for stroke sets our ambition for optimal stroke prevention and care. Specialist comprehensive regional stroke centres offer opportunities to pool expertise, strengthen our workforce and services, and improve timely access to treatment, including round-the-clock access to life-saving thrombectomy. Diolch.

17:30
6. Statement by the Cabinet Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning: Review of the Local Government funding formula

We will move now to item 6, a statement by the Cabinet Minister for Local Government, Housing and Planning, a review of the local government funding formula. I call on the Cabinet Minister, Siân Gwenllian.

Thank you very much, Dirprwy Lywydd. Today, I want to update Members on the review of the local government funding formula. Every year, the local government settlement distributes billions of pounds of core funding between Wales's 22 local authorities. Those authorities serve communities with different populations, characteristics and needs, and they face different challenges in delivering local services. Funding through the settlement gives the local authorities the flexibility to respond to those local needs and aspirations. Our responsibility is to ensure that the evidence underpinning that distribution is robust, up to date, and that it reflects those differences fairly.

Population will always be a fundamental issue in the distribution of funding, but population alone cannot fully reflect the demand placed on local services, nor the cost of providing them. The formula must also consider deprivation and demographic change, alongside the rurality and population sparsity of particular areas, alongside wider service pressures. Some of the evidence used to reflect those factors is now significantly out of date.

The work to review and update the formula has two complementary strands. The first strand is independent research carried out by the Wales Centre for Public Policy, which considers the broader principles and methodologies that underpin funding distribution. It is examining approaches used elsewhere, the drivers of needs and costs reflected in those approaches, and how they account for issues such as rurality and population sparsity. The report stemming from the research is expected to be published in summer 2027.

The second strand is the detailed technical review being undertaken by the Welsh Government in partnership with local government. This involves updating the evidence, indicators and weightings that underpin the formula, with the intention of retaining its needs-based methodology, which is already established. We have delivered our first 100 days commitment by commissioning the independent research and, together, both strands are progressing our wider programme for government commitment to ensure that the formula better reflects the real cost of delivering services in different parts of Wales.

The technical review is not simply a matter of replacing old data with new. Proper recalibration means reviewing the underlying evidence, the indicators and the basic assumptions and testing how well they reflect current patterns in terms of needs and expenditure. Also, census-based indicators must be reconstructed using newer available data, and that requires complex mapping between different geographical areas.

Despite the complexity, this work is progressing well across a number of fronts. On education, we have used 

we have used detailed school-level information to analyse the main areas of expenditure and the work of updating that formula is well advanced.

On social care, recent engagement with practitioners has confirmed that further time will be needed to develop the consistent and robust data needed for detailed modelling. Preliminary analysis is also under way across other areas of the formula.

Quality assurance processes, analytical challenge and peer review are also being built into the work. Changes to a formula distributing such significant levels of public funding must be based on strong evidence and on shared confidence.

I have been clear throughout that this review must be delivered in partnership with local government, which is helping to shape the programme through the arrangements of the distribution sub-group and the finance sub-group. Practitioners are also contributing their detailed knowledge of services, data and delivery pressures.

The review must also strike an appropriate balance between those factors affecting relative need. Our task is not to choose between urban and rural Wales, nor to focus on any one factor at the expense of others. It is rather to understand how population, deprivation, rurality and other factors can affect relative need and service delivery costs.

Deprivation exists in both rural and urban communities. Rurality and sparsity can create additional costs, while demographic change can affect the nature and the scale of demand. The significance of these factors may also vary between services.

The review concerns how the funding available to local government is distributed between authorities. It does not determine the overall amount of funding available to local government. It is also important to bear in mind that the funding distributed through the settlement is unhypothecated. Calculations within individual elements of the formula help assess relative need and distribute the available funding. They are not targets for what an authority should spend on particular services. Those decisions remain matters for local authorities, reflecting local priorities, pressures and statutory responsibilities.

We are continuing to work towards the implementation of technical changes through the 2028-29 local government settlement where the evidence and analysis are sufficiently developed. A longer timetable would be needed for the personal social services elements, reflecting the complexity of developing and collecting the detailed, consistent data required across Wales.

The implementation work also means that sufficient time must be allowed to test and validate the evidence, assess the overall effects and provide authorities with the information that they need for financial planning.

Fairness must extend not only to the design of the formula, but also to how any changes are introduced. So, consideration of transition, phasing and damping arrangements is therefore being embedded throughout the review, alongside the analytical work.

This aim of this review is not to design a formula that favours one type of authority or one part of Wales over another. The intention is to ensure that genuine differences in relative need and service delivery costs are properly reflected, and that the funding available to local government is distributed as fairly as possible.

We will continue to take this work forward carefully, transparently, and in partnership with local government. Our objective is to ensure a robust, evidence-based formula in which we can all have confidence.

17:35

Thank you. In the absence of Reform UK, I will go to the Labour benches—Vikki Howells.

Diolch, Dirprwy Lywydd. I thank the Minister for re-announcing the review of the local government formula. The last Welsh Labour Government engaged with the Wales Centre for Public Policy to overhaul the funding formula with specific reference to the impact of the formula on rural authorities. This followed intense lobbying by rural authorities

by rural authorities unhappy at the operation of a needs-based formula. The real problem is that austerity led to local government settlements falling way below the rates of inflation and demand growth experienced by councils. The Minister is fiddling while Welsh local government burns. This year, the WLGA estimates combined pressures on local government are worth £554 million—the equivalent to 6.3 per cent of net revenue expenditure. In response, the Minister is working on a likely 2.8 per cent uplift in the revenue support grant worth £197 million, which would leave a shortfall of £357 million—equivalent to a 17 per cent increase on council tax. In this context, RSG reviews are not enough. What is the Minister going to do about the underfunding of local government? How is she going to prevent massive council tax rises with service cuts to match?

It is evident that the Government's intent is to move resources to the rural councils controlled by Plaid Cymru. All this will do is move around the pain of not having enough resources in the local authority funding system. Minister, you are proposing musical chairs for inadequate funding of councils. Councils growing their population get a higher percentage of RSG from the formula based on population-weighted factors. Rural councils tend to have slow population growth, leading to relatively lower increases in RSG. The councils that will lose will be the growing councils with deprivation and social challenges, like Newport, Cardiff and the Valleys. The current formula is based on fairness. Moving away from the principle of fairness to favour rurality is, we would argue, shameless gerrymandering of the formula by Plaid Cymru.

The lowest RSG payout each year tends to be Monmouth and the Vale of Glamorgan, and the highest in Blaenau Gwent and Merthyr. Why? Seventy-five per cent of dwellings in Monmouthshire are in council tax band D or above and over half of dwellings in Blaenau Gwent and Merthyr Tydfil are in council tax band A. The fairest way of changing financial support for each authority will be by undertaking a revaluation of council tax. Unfortunately, the new Welsh Government bottled doing that.

Our Welsh Labour colleague Mike Hedges has given an example of what formula changes can do. He sat on a panel that changed the formula factors for roads, where maintenance moved from 55 per cent population and 45 per cent road length to 50 per cent of each. Sounds reasonable. The repercussion was that money moved from urban areas such as Cardiff, Swansea and Newport, with large numbers of major roads, to Ceredigion and Powys, with a large number of minor roads with little traffic. The sums were substantial.

Local government financial needs are not being met. There are areas of expenditure pressure in all local councils, including social care, children's services, additional learning needs and homelessness, which Labour successfully got increased in the supplementary budget in the teeth of Plaid Cymru opposition. Labour requests that, in any review, the Green Book calculations for service need for each council are identified and published, that widespread consultations take place, including with local authorities and academics before any final decision on a new formula is produced, that the 2026-27 calculations are re-run, and that change recommended from the review is shown against current provision. Not just the final figures; show your working so that you can be held accountable for what you propose to take from the many to give to the few. In conclusion, if you really want to help local government, get your Cabinet to raise RSG by a minimum of 4 per cent plus investment in children through supporting the growth in demand for ALN.

17:40

Thank you very much. And, of course, we do recognise that local authorities continue to face substantial financial pressures; the cake isn't large enough. But despite the challenging financial context, the budget that we've heard outlined this afternoon does provide a real-terms increase for the local government settlement within a resource budget that is reduced, of course. This, of course, is the beginning of the process, and we will listen to Senedd scrutiny and will continue discussions with other parties over the next few weeks on the settlement and other issues within the budget published just this afternoon.

published just this afternoon. I totally reject the appalling accusation that there is some intention here to shift funds to rural areas and to Plaid Cymru-controlled councils. I take that as a personal insult, because fairness is what drives every thing that I try to do. And certainly, there is a perception at the moment that there are local authorities that feel that the formula doesn't fully recognise the particular pressures that they face, or the costs attached to providing services within their communities. It is therefore appropriate that we look in earnest at the formula, which is very dated, the various different indicators. It's been 20 years since that last happened, and I wonder why it didn't happen until we had a Plaid Cymru Government in place that wants to deliver fairness for all parts of Wales, and to see that reflected in the funding formula.

And, of course, there will be plenty of time for everyone to scrutinise any changes that may emerge in detail. We may find that the formula is fair as it currently stands. Who knows? We are simply at the starting post of this work. But if changes were introduced, there will be full engagement with local government. Local government is a core part of the work that is currently ongoing. There are two groups—there's the distribution sub-group and the finance subgroup—representing different aspects of local government who are playing a central role in the work that is currently ongoing. I look forward to seeing this happen so that we can look to see whether the situation as it currently stands is sustainable.

17:45

Can I thank you, Cabinet Minister, for today's statement? I'd like to begin by welcoming the fact that the Welsh Government has finally recognised what we and others have been saying for years: that the local government funding formula needs to be reviewed. The current formula has remained largely unaltered, as you said, for well over two decades, but during that time, Wales has changed. Demographics, levels of rurality have changed, demand on social care has increased. Add to this new legislative burdens, and the pressures facing councils have significantly increased too. So, if the review concludes that some authorities have been receiving a better settlement than others, or that the formula does not adequately reflect need, then, frankly, that should not surprise anyone. The question is not whether a review is needed—it clearly is. The question is: why has it taken so long?

The previous Government would not address this elephant in the room. For years, we and others had raised concerns that the existing arrangements do not always fairly reflect the real cost of delivering services, particularly in rural areas and in counties with significant pressures. Yes, a greater quantum is needed, and we should always be striving for that, but whatever the size of the cake is, it needs to be cut up fairly, and it clearly isn't being cut up fairly at the moment.

I was pleased Plaid Cymru finally acknowledged in its 2026 manifesto that the local government funding formula should be reviewed and reformed, so that it fairly reflects the realities of serving largely rural populations. So, the need for change is not new. Many in the local government family could see it, but many others chose not to. Of course, turkeys don't vote for Christmas. It is disappointing that we won't see the outcomes of a review until mid 2027, so, clearly, some councils will have to tolerate the situation for at least another year, which is unfortunate.

Councils are facing acute financial pressures today. Many will see some services struggle, possibly close, and once they've gone, they've gone for good. We believe the review will identify genuine flaws in the system. If the outcome does show there are problems, how long will it be, Cabinet Minister, before we see meaningful change? Will the Government make adjustments if obvious issues are identified